"It was wrong to do this," said the angel — Summary

Stephen CraneNachdenklich

"It was wrong to do this," said the angel. "You should live like a flower, Holding malice like a puppy, Waging war like a lambkin."

"Not so," quoth the man Who had no fear of spirits; "It is only wrong for angels Who can live like the flowers, Holding malice like the puppies, Waging war like the lambkins."

Das ganze Gedicht zeigenGedicht einklappen

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

An angel scolds someone—likely a man—for doing something wrong, urging him to live with the harmlessness of a flower, to hold malice as if it were a puppy, and to wage war with the meekness of a lamb. The advice is beautifully innocent, but it comes from a being who doesn’t share human limits. The man fires back without fear, pointing out that such a soft existence is only wrong for angels, who actually can live that way. The mood is wry and unapologetic. There’s a blunt recognition that human life demands something tougher, something angels don’t have to understand. It’s not a rejection of goodness, but a pushback against impractical ideals, delivered with a fearless shrug.

Mehr von Stephen Crane

Alle Gedichte
NachdenklichStephen Crane

In a lonely place,

In a lonely place, I encountered a sage Who sat, all still, Regarding a newspaper.
TraurigStephen Crane

God lay dead in heaven

God lay dead in heaven; Angels sang the hymn of the end; Purple winds went moaning, Their wings drip-dripping
VerträumtStephen Crane

Ay, workman, make me a dream,

Ay, workman, make me a dream, A dream for my love. Cunningly weave sunlight, Breezes, and flowers.