Song — Summary

AT poet's tears, Sweeter than any smiles but hers, She laughs; I sigh; And yet I could not live if she should die.

And when in June Once more the cuckoo spoils his tune, She laughs at sighs; And yet she says she loves me till she dies.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

In this tiny, charged lyric, the speaker is caught between his own melancholy and the woman’s bright, teasing laughter. He offers “poet’s tears,” but she laughs at them, and that laughter is sweeter to him than any smile — except hers. It’s a pattern: he sighs, she laughs, and yet he confesses he couldn’t live if she died. The same game plays out in June, when the cuckoo’s song goes off-kilter. Again she laughs at sighs, and this time she swears she loves him until death. The mood is intimate and precarious — a smile stretched over a deep seriousness. The repeated “die” that closes each stanza never lets the lightness float away entirely. Instead, the poem holds a fragile balance: her laughter seems to mock his sadness, but it also binds them together, making their affection feel both ordinary and desperately precious.

More by Edward Thomas

All poems
AnxiousEdward Thomas

The New House

Now first, as I shut the door, I was alone In the new house; and the wind Began to moan.
ContemplativeEdward Thomas

Tears

IT seems I have no tears left. They should have fallen-- Their ghosts, if tears have ghosts, did fall--that day When twenty hounds streamed by me, not yet combed out
AnxiousEdward Thomas

Out in the Dark

OUT in the dark over the snow The fallow fawns invisible go With the fallow doe; And the winds blow