Is Heaven a Physician? — Summary

Emily DickinsonContemplative

Is Heaven a Physician? They say that He can heal -- But Medicine Posthumous Is unavailable -- Is Heaven an Exchequer? They speak of what we owe -- But that negotiation I'm not a Party to --

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

The speaker poses two pointed, almost childlike questions. First, she asks if Heaven is a doctor. People say God can heal, but a cure that only comes after death isn’t much use to the living. Then she wonders if Heaven is a sort of heavenly bank, demanding payment for what we owe. But she immediately notes that she was never invited to that negotiation—she didn’t agree to the terms. There’s a cool, defiant edge here. The speaker doesn’t rage; she simply points out the practical flaw in these consoling beliefs. The mood is wry and skeptical, turning religious platitudes into everyday absurdities. It feels as if she’s politely but firmly refusing to take part in a deal she never made.

More by Emily Dickinson

All poems
ContemplativeEmily Dickinson

Too happy Time dissolves itself

Too happy Time dissolves itself And leaves no remnant by -- 'Tis Anguish not a Feather hath Or too much weight to fly --
ContemplativeEmily Dickinson

It sounded as if the Streets were running

It sounded as if the Streets were running And then -- the Streets stood still -- Eclipse -- was all we could see at the Window And Awe -- was all we could feel.