Julian Scott — Summary

Toward the last The truth of others was untruth to me; The justice of others injustice to me; Their reasons for death, reasons with me for life; Their reasons for life, reasons with me for death; I would have killed those they saved, And save those they killed. And I saw how a god, if brought to earth, Must act out what he saw and thought, And could not live in this world of men And act among them side by side Without continual clashes. The dust’s for crawling, heaven’s for flying— Wherefore, O soul, whose wings are grown, Soar upward to the sun!

Mostra tutta la poesiaComprimi la poesia

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Julian Scott looks back near the end of his life and describes how completely out of step he felt with everyone around him. Their truths seemed false to him, their justice felt unjust, and their reasons for living or dying were reversed from his own. He would have killed those they saved and saved those they killed. This is not simple stubbornness; he compares himself to a god forced to live on earth, someone who cannot move among human beings without constant clashes. The mood is isolated and defiant, yet also strangely calm. He sounds less bitter than exhausted, as if he has long accepted that he does not belong here. Earth is for crawling, he says, and heaven is for flying. Since his soul already has wings, the only answer is to rise toward the sun and leave the world behind.

Leggi anche

Altro di Edgar Lee Masters

Tutte le poesie
ArrabbiatoEdgar Lee Masters

Carl Hamblin

The press of the Spoon River Clarion was wrecked, And I was tarred and feathered, For publishing this on the day the Anarchists were hanged in Chicago:
ArrabbiatoEdgar Lee Masters

Robert Fulton Tanner

If a man could bite the giant hand That catches and destroys him, As I was bitten by a rat While demonstrating my patent trap,
AllegroEdgar Lee Masters

Penniwit, the Artist

I lost my patronage in Spoon River From trying to put my mind in the camera To catch the soul of the person. The very best picture I ever took