In Memoriam (Easter, 1915) — Poem analysis

THE flowers left thick at nightfall in the wood This Eastertide call into mind the men, Now far from home, who, with their sweethearts, should Have gathered them and will do never again.

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Four lines, one sentence, and not a single corpse in sight. Edward Thomas's "In Memoriam (Easter, 1915)" mourns soldiers without describing a battlefield, a wound or an enemy. All it gives us is a wood at dusk and a scattering of flowers that nobody has taken home. The grief is carried by what is missing: the men who should have been there to pick them.

The central idea is that war's loss shows up in small, ordinary things. The flowers "left thick at nightfall in the wood" are an image of waste. "Thick" suggests abundance, a spring that carries on regardless, while "left" quietly turns that abundance into abandonment. The flowers aren't dead or damaged. They are simply unclaimed, and that is how the poem makes absence visible. The phrase "with their sweethearts" adds a second loss. Picking flowers in a wood at evening sounds like a courtship ritual, so the missing men also stand for missing couples, missing walks, a whole small future that has been cancelled.

The sentence structure does much of the emotional work. Everything is held back until the last line. The subject, "The flowers", comes first, and its verb, "call into mind", arrives only in line two. Then comes the key phrase "who, with their sweethearts, should / Have gathered them." The line break after "should" is the most important pause in the poem. It leaves a sense of duty or expectation hanging in mid-air, and the next line completes it with a denial: "and will do never again." The wording is also worth noticing. Ordinary English would say "will never do again," but Thomas puts "never again" at the very end, so the poem closes on the two words that make the loss permanent.

The rhyme scheme is a plain ABAB: "wood" with "should", "men" with "again". These pairings are quietly meaningful. "Wood" and "should" tie the place to the obligation, so that the setting itself seems to ask a question of the absent. "Men" and "again" pair the people with the finality of their absence, and the final rhyme sounds like a door closing. The metre is mostly steady iambic pentameter, the familiar English line, which gives the poem a calm, almost conversational dignity. The last line is the exception. If you pronounce "gathered" in full, it tips one syllable over ten, and that small stretch makes the sentence sag toward its ending, as though the speaker's voice is running out.

The vocabulary is modest. Nearly every word is short and everyday, apart from compounds like "nightfall", "Eastertide" and "sweethearts", which have a gentle, old-fashioned, countryside feel. "Eastertide" is the richest of them. Easter is the Christian season of resurrection and return, and the poem sets that against men who, in the poem's phrase, "will do never again" what they once did. Thomas never says the word "dead", and he doesn't need to. "Now far from home" is a euphemism that sounds almost like ordinary distance, and the flat finality of the last line shows what it really means. The title's "In Memoriam" is the language of memorials and gravestones, and it dates the poem to one particular Easter, which makes it feel like a personal act of remembering rather than a general statement about war.

The poem's significance lies in this restraint. It makes no appeal to glory, honour or the enemy, and it doesn't shout. Instead it trusts one image to hold the whole weight of loss. Thomas is generally known as a poet of the English countryside, and here the landscape does the mourning for him. Knowing that he himself was killed in the war, in 1917, gives these four lines an extra shadow. But the poem works without that knowledge. Anyone who has seen an object left behind by someone who isn't coming back will recognise what it describes: the way grief lodges in a small, unfinished action rather than in a grand statement.

Read also

More by Edward Thomas

All poems
ContemplativeEdward Thomas

Some Eyes Condemn

SOME eyes condemn the earth they gaze upon: Some wait patiently till they know far more Than earth can tell them: some laugh at the whole As folly of another's making: one
ContemplativeEdward Thomas

Fifty Faggots

THERE they stand, on their ends, the fifty faggots That once were underwood of hazel and ash In Jenny Pinks's Copse. Now, by the hedge Close packed, they make a thicket fancy alone
ContemplativeEdward Thomas

The Dark Forest

DARK is the forest and deep, and overhead Hang stars like seeds of light In vain, though not since they were sown was bred Anything more bright.