Lights Out — Poem analysis

Edward ThomasContemplative

I HAVE come to the borders of sleep, The unfathomable deep Forest where all must lose Their way, however straight, Or winding, soon or late; They cannot choose.

Many a road and track That, since the dawn's first crack, Up to the forest brink, Deceived the travellers Suddenly now blurs, And in they sink.

Here love ends, Despair, ambition ends, All pleasure and all trouble, Although most sweet or bitter, Here ends in sleep that is sweeter Than tasks most noble.

There is not any book Or face of dearest look That I would not turn from now To go into the unknown I must enter and leave alone I know not how.

The tall forest towers; Its cloudy foliage lowers Ahead, shelf above shelf; Its silence I hear and obey That I may lose my way And myself.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Edward Thomas's «Lights Out» begins at a threshold: "I have come to the borders of sleep." The title sounds like a bedtime order, and the poem treats falling asleep as a journey that ends at the edge of a vast forest. Everyone must enter it, and nobody keeps their bearings. Its central idea is that this loss is not a defeat. By the last line the speaker wants to be lost, and he describes the wish as obedience rather than surrender.

The forest is the poem's governing image, and it is built from the speaker's day. In the second stanza the "road and track" that have led travellers since "the dawn's first crack" reach the forest's edge and "blur." The verb suits both fading light and drooping eyes. Then comes "in they sink," where the inverted word order makes the sinking feel as inevitable as the act itself. The first stanza has already ruled out any resistance: whether our path has been "straight, / Or winding," we "cannot choose." The word "must" sets the tone here, and the poem later quietly overturns it.

The third stanza is the most surprising. Love, despair and ambition all stop at the forest's edge, and the speaker is even-handed about it: "pleasure" and "trouble," the "sweet" and the "bitter," are all dissolved. Then he claims that sleep is "sweeter / Than tasks most noble." Few poems would rank rest above noble work so plainly, and the plainness is what convinces. The fourth stanza makes the same point in personal terms. He would turn from "any book / Or face of dearest look," which are the things a person usually clings to. What draws him is "the unknown," and the poem admits that he must enter it "alone" and "I know not how." That admission keeps the calm from being glib. The poem never says what sleep is, or whether it is only sleep.

Formally, the poem is quiet and orderly. Every stanza has six lines rhymed aabccb, and the pattern holds even where the language loosens. In the second stanza "travellers" and "blurs" are only a half-rhyme. In the third, "trouble" and "noble" are close but not exact, and the word "ends" is simply repeated at the start of two lines, as though the poem were closing one door after another. Line lengths vary, with short lines such as "The unfathomable deep" set against longer ones, so the verse seems to drift and settle like a mind losing its grip. The vocabulary is mostly short, plain words, and "unfathomable" stands out because it is the one long word describing something too deep to measure.

The last stanza moves from the speaker's feelings to the forest itself. "The tall forest towers; / Its cloudy foliage lowers / Ahead, shelf above shelf." "Lowers" can mean to hang overhead and to look threatening, so the scene is not entirely comforting. The leaves are stacked in layers like shelves, which, after the rejected "book," may be a small ironic echo. Then comes the paradox "Its silence I hear and obey." A silence cannot give orders, yet the speaker listens to it as if it did. The obedience has a purpose: "That I may lose my way / And myself." The ending turns the first stanza around. There, all "must lose / Their way." Here, "may" replaces "must," and compulsion becomes consent. The closing words, "And myself," are the shortest line in the poem. It is a very small phrase for the loss of a whole identity, and it can be read as terror or as relief. The poem leaves that choice to the reader.

That openness is a large part of why «Lights Out» matters. It takes something everyone does every night and makes it feel like a rite of passage, without melodrama and without claiming to know what lies beyond the trees. A reader may hear sleep, death, or both. The calm control of the rhymes and the plain wording make the unknown feel less like a threat than like a place the speaker has chosen to go.

Read also

More by Edward Thomas

All poems
ContemplativeEdward Thomas

Some Eyes Condemn

SOME eyes condemn the earth they gaze upon: Some wait patiently till they know far more Than earth can tell them: some laugh at the whole As folly of another's making: one
CheerfulEdward Thomas

If I Should Ever by Chance

IF I should ever by chance grow rich I'll buy Codham, Cockridden, and Childerditch, Roses, Pyrgo, and Lapwater, And let them all to my elder daughter.
ContemplativeEdward Thomas

There Was a Time

THERE was a time when this poor frame was whole And I had youth and never another care, Or none that should have troubled a strong soul. Yet, except sometimes in a frosty air