The Combe — Poem analysis

Edward ThomasContemplative

THE Combe was ever dark, ancient and dark. Its mouth is stopped with bramble, thorn, and briar; And no one scrambles over the sliding chalk By beech and yew and perishing juniper Down the half precipices of its sides, with roots And rabbit holes for steps. The sun of Winter, The moon of Summer, and all the singing birds Except the missel-thrush that loves juniper, Are quite shut out. But far more ancient and dark The Combe looks since they killed the badger there, Dug him out and gave him to the hounds, That most ancient Briton of English beasts.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Edward Thomas, an English poet who wrote about the countryside in a plain, speaking voice, needs only twelve lines to build a place you would never want to enter, and then to make it worse. The Combe begins as a landscape of bare fact: "ancient and dark," choked at its mouth with "bramble, thorn, and briar," too steep and crumbly for anyone to climb. In the last four lines a single act of cruelty changes how the whole place looks. The central idea is that human violence can darken a landscape that was already dark, and that the loss falls on something older than the people who cause it.

The opening line sets the poem's habit of repetition: "dark, ancient and dark." The word *dark* appears at both ends of the line, like a door closing. Then comes personification: the Combe has a "mouth," and it "is stopped," as if silenced or corked. The long sentence that follows tells us what nobody does. No one scrambles down "the sliding chalk," past "beech and yew and perishing juniper." The steps are "roots / And rabbit holes," a staircase made for animals, not walkers. "Perishing" is a sharp choice. It tells us the juniper is dying, but it also carries the sense of bitter cold.

The next sentence lists what the Combe keeps out. "The sun of Winter, / The moon of Summer, and all the singing birds" are "quite shut out." The pairing crosses the seasons, so light is refused by day and by night, in cold and in warmth. "Quite shut out" is oddly polite, almost the language of a closed door in a hallway. Then comes one exception: "the missel-thrush that loves juniper." It is the only warm verb in the poem before the turn, and it attaches affection to the very plant we were just told is perishing. Juniper has now appeared twice, so the reader half-believes the place is bleak but not hostile, a home for whatever suits it.

The turn comes with "But far more ancient and dark." Thomas repeats the opening words and simply adds "far more." Nothing in the landscape has changed. What has changed is the Combe's look, "since they killed the badger there." The "they" is unnamed and the verbs are blunt: "killed," "Dug him out," "gave him to the hounds." There are almost no adjectives, and the sentence is a chain of plain actions joined by "and." The horror comes from the flat telling. The badger is "him," not "it." Since his home was underground, the darkness that sheltered him is the very thing that was broken into.

The last line, "That most ancient Briton of English beasts," arrives like an afterthought, hung on the sentence without a verb. The poem ends on a title of honour rather than an outcry. *Ancient* has now climbed a ladder: "ancient," "far more ancient," "most ancient." The contrast of "Briton" and "English" suggests, as an inference, that the badger was here before the people who killed him, the original native killed by latecomers. The darkness of the Combe becomes a matter of history and conscience as well as shade.

The form supports this restraint. There is no rhyme, and the lines are loosely five-beat, often running over the line-end ("with roots / And rabbit holes for steps"; "The sun of Winter, / The moon of Summer"). The effect is of someone talking as he walks. Without rhyme there is no tidy click at the finish. The poem simply stops, leaving the killing as a fact. Sound still does quiet work: the stacked consonants of "bramble, thorn, and briar" feel thorny in the mouth, and the hard *d* in "Dug him out" lands like a spade.

The poem matters because it trusts the reader. Thomas never says the killing was wrong. He lets repeated words and a changed landscape carry the judgment. The verb "looks" is key: the Combe seems darker because of what we now know. That sense of a place holding the memory of what was done in it is what lingers after the final full stop.

Read also

More by Edward Thomas

All poems
ContemplativeEdward Thomas

What Will They Do?

What will they do when I am gone? It is plain That they will do without me as the rain Can do without the flowers and the grass That profit by it and must perish without.
DreamyEdward Thomas

Swedes

THEY have taken the gable from the roof of clay On the long swede pile. They have let in the sun To the white and gold and purple of curled fronds Unsunned. It is a sight more tender-gorgeous
DreamyEdward Thomas

The Penny Whistle

THE new moon hangs like an ivory bugle In the naked frosty blue; And the ghylls of the forest, already blackened By Winter, are blackened anew.