Home — Poem analysis

Edward ThomasContemplative

OFTEN I had gone this way before: But now it seemed I never could be And never had been anywhere else; 'Twas home; one nationality We had, I and the birds that sang, One memory.

They welcomed me. I had come back That eve somehow from somewhere far: The April mist, the chill, the calm, Meant the same thing familiar And pleasant to us, and strange too, Yet with no bar.

The thrush on the oaktop in the lane Sang his last song, or last but one; And as he ended, on the elm Another had but just begun His last; they knew no more than I The day was done.

Then past his dark white cottage front A labourer went along, his tread Slow, half with weariness, half with ease; And, through the silence, from his shed The sound of sawing rounded all That silence said.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Nothing dramatic happens in Edward Thomas's "Home." A man walks down a lane he has walked many times, evening comes on, two thrushes sing, a labourer passes, and someone saws wood. Yet the speaker discovers something he did not expect: this ordinary path has become the only place he has ever belonged. The poem's central idea is that home is not a building but a sudden, quiet sense of being absorbed into a place. The speaker never mentions a house of his own. The only cottage in the poem belongs to someone else.

The opening line sets up a hinge: "Often I had gone this way before: / But now..." The colon and the "But" mark the moment familiarity turns into something deeper. The line break then does careful work. "I never could be" stops dead at the end of the line, as if the speaker were cancelling himself out, before the sentence recovers with "And never had been anywhere else." Past and future fall away and only the present remains. The next word is blunt and old-fashioned: "'Twas home." Then comes a surprising choice, "nationality." It is a political word, usually about passports and borders, but here it is shared by a man and the singing birds. Belonging is imagined as citizenship in a landscape, in which a human has no higher rank than a bird.

The second stanza is deliberately vague. The speaker has come back "somehow from somewhere far," and the soft repeated *s* sounds match his uncertainty about where he has been. The April mist, chill and calm "meant the same thing / familiar / And pleasant to us, and strange too, / Yet with no bar." The strangeness is not removed, only made harmless. A "bar" is a gate or barrier, a fitting image for a country lane, and here nothing stands in the way.

The form supports this gentleness. Each six-line stanza rhymes only on lines two, four and six, and each stanza finds a new sound: *be / nationality / memory*, then *far / familiar / bar*, *one / begun / done*, and *tread / shed / said*. The unrhymed lines in between leave the stanzas slightly loose, so the rhymes arrive like a half-heard chime rather than a snap. The metre is roughly four beats a line but stays close to speech, and sentences spill across line endings. Each stanza also closes on a shortened line: "One memory." "Yet with no bar." "The day was done." "That silence said." These work like a footstep slowing or a breath let out.

The thrushes are rendered with a countryman's exactness. One "sang his last song, or last but one," and as he finishes another "had but just begun / His last." The song is passed along like a relay, and the repeated "last" gives the scene a faint elegiac glow. The birds "knew no more than I / The day was done," which puts speaker and birds in the same dusk, equally unaware of its ending.

The final stanza adds a human figure. The labourer passes "his dark white cottage front," an apparent contradiction that catches whitewash dimmed by dusk. His tread is "half with weariness, half with ease," a balance that mirrors the poem's own mixture of tiredness and comfort. Then, "through the silence," comes the sawing from the shed, which "rounded all / That silence said." Silence is made to speak, and the sound completes what it says the way a full stop completes a sentence. The poem ends not with a conclusion but with an ordinary noise.

Thomas came to poetry late, after years as a prose writer, and Robert Frost encouraged him. He was killed at Arras in 1917. "Home" never mentions war, but a reader who knows this may hear "last song" and "the day was done" with extra weight. That is an inference from knowing the life, not something the poem states. What makes the poem significant is how little it asserts. It treats belonging as a fleeting perception that arrives unannounced, among birds, weather and a neighbour's labour, and it trusts plain words and a few small sounds to hold that feeling.

Read also

More by Edward Thomas

All poems
ContemplativeEdward Thomas

What Will They Do?

What will they do when I am gone? It is plain That they will do without me as the rain Can do without the flowers and the grass That profit by it and must perish without.
DreamyEdward Thomas

Swedes

THEY have taken the gable from the roof of clay On the long swede pile. They have let in the sun To the white and gold and purple of curled fronds Unsunned. It is a sight more tender-gorgeous
DreamyEdward Thomas

The Penny Whistle

THE new moon hangs like an ivory bugle In the naked frosty blue; And the ghylls of the forest, already blackened By Winter, are blackened anew.