For Death -- or rather — Poem analysis

Emily DickinsonContemplative

For Death -- or rather For the Things 'twould buy -- This -- put away Life's Opportunity --

The Things that Death will buy Are Room -- Escape from Circumstances -- And a Name --

With Gifts of Life How Death's Gifts may compare -- We know not -- For the Rates -- lie Here --

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Dickinson borrows the language of the marketplace and aims it at the biggest subject there is. In these twelve lines death is something you purchase, and the poem is oddly businesslike about it. The currency is "Life's Opportunity," and once it is "put away," the deal is done. There is no weeping or consolation here, only an exchange and an unsettling question about whether the goods are worth the price.

The poem starts by correcting itself: "For Death -- or rather / For the Things 'twould buy." The speaker revises mid-sentence, as if death itself were never the real object of desire, only a means to something else, the way a ticket is not the journey. That small adjustment moves death from the realm of fear into the realm of bargaining. The grammar of the first stanza is also compressed. "This" hangs in the air, pointing at the sacrifice, and the sentence seems to arrive only after a stumble. Dickinson often packs her syntax tightly, and readers have to supply connections the poem leaves out.

The second stanza itemises what is on sale: "Room," "Escape from Circumstances," and "And a Name." The lines shrink to almost nothing, and "Room --" stands alone like a label in a shop window. Each item is rich in possible meaning. "Room" could suggest space to breathe or the narrow room of a grave, and the poem lets both ideas sit together. "Circumstances" is a heavy, abstract word, and it makes ordinary life sound like a set of walls to be escaped. "A Name" might mean lasting reputation or the name carved on a stone. The poem does not say, but the little "And" before it makes this last item feel like the prize at the end of the list.

Dickinson's habits of punctuation and capitalisation do real work here. Capitals fall on "Death," "Things," "Room," "Circumstances," "Name," "Gifts," and "Rates," so that abstractions look like entries in a ledger. The dashes break the lines into hesitations, as if the speaker is counting out coins. The form is three quatrains of short lines, with two or three stresses each, which gives a compact, hymn-like shape. But the rhyme is sparse and slippery. The first stanza barely rhymes at all. "Room" and "Name" are linked only by their closing *m*, and "compare" and "Here" echo each other loosely through their final *r*. Because the sound never settles into a neat pattern, the poem feels slightly unfinished, which suits its subject.

The last stanza is where the transaction turns uncomfortable. How do life's gifts "compare" with death's? "We know not." Then comes the final line: "For the Rates -- lie Here." On the surface this means the prices are paid on this side of the grave, in this life. But "lie" is a loaded verb, and a reader might also catch a faint suggestion of something deceptive, though the poem never insists on it. Either way, the logic is sharp. We can see the price, because it is our own life, but the goods are delivered somewhere we cannot inspect beforehand. The buyer has to pay first and trust completely. The poem also ends on the word "Here," which pins us to the living world where the paying must happen.

What makes the poem significant is this mix of coolness and daring. Dickinson, who lived in Amherst, Massachusetts (1830–1886) and wrote nearly 1,800 poems, most of them unpublished in her lifetime, was often willing to look at death without sentimentality. This poem does so by being almost bureaucratic about it. It never tells us who the speaker is or why the opportunity is surrendered, so the poem can be read as being about literal death, about renunciation, or about giving up living for the sake of a "Name." That openness is part of its power. It also makes an honest admission, since the speaker does not claim to know what lies beyond. All she offers is the one certain fact, that the price is everything we have, and she leaves the reader to decide whether that is a bargain.

Read also

More by Emily Dickinson

All poems
ContemplativeEmily Dickinson

Consulting summer's clock,

Consulting summer's clock, But half the hours remain. I ascertain it with a shock -- I shall not look again.
ContemplativeEmily Dickinson

Nature -- the Gentlest Mother is,

Nature -- the Gentlest Mother is, Impatient of no Child -- The feeblest -- or the waywardest -- Her Admonition mild --
ContemplativeEmily Dickinson

The Moon upon her fluent Route

The Moon upon her fluent Route Defiant of a Road -- The Star's Etruscan Argument Substantiate a God --