A Murmur in the Trees -- to note — Poem analysis

A Murmur in the Trees -- to note -- Not loud enough -- for Wind -- A Star -- not far enough to seek -- Nor near enough -- to find --

A long -- long Yellow -- on the Lawn -- A Hubbub -- as of feet -- Not audible -- as Ours -- to Us -- But dapperer -- More Sweet --

A Hurrying Home of little Men To Houses unperceived -- All this -- and more -- if I should tell -- Would never be believed --

Of Robins in the Trundle bed How many I espy Whose Nightgowns could not hide the Wings -- Although I heard them try --

But then I promised ne'er to tell -- How could I break My Word? So go your Way -- and I'll go Mine -- No fear you'll miss the Road.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Dickinson begins with things that barely count as events. A "Murmur in the Trees" is "Not loud enough -- for Wind," and a star is "not far enough to seek / Nor near enough -- to find." The whole first stanza is built from negatives and near-misses, a list of what falls just short of being noticed. The poem lives in that narrow band between perceiving and imagining, and the rest of it walks into the gap.

What the speaker finds there is a miniature society. Across the lawn, in what the judging-by-the-imagery reader may take for late-day sunlight ("A long -- long Yellow"), there is a "Hubbub, as of feet." The tiny crowd is "Not audible -- as Ours -- to Us," yet it is "dapperer -- More Sweet." That small comparison turns the usual hierarchy upside down: human noise becomes the coarse one, and the hidden creatures get the better manners and the better tailoring. Then comes "A Hurrying Home of little Men / To Houses unperceived," which sounds like a village at closing time, everyone heading in for the evening. Dickinson doesn't explain who these figures are. She lets them stay half-visible, and that is where their charm comes from.

The fourth stanza is where the poem turns openly playful. Robins sleep in a "Trundle bed," the low children's bed that slides under a larger one, and their "Nightgowns could not hide the Wings." The joke is in the last line: "Although I heard them try." We can almost hear the rustle of small bodies fidgeting under cloth, and the poem pictures birds as children caught pretending. Dickinson doesn't give the birds a lesson or a moral. She simply gives them bedclothes.

The ending changes the poem's mood. The speaker says she has "promised ne'er to tell" and asks, "How could I break My Word?" That is a lovely contradiction, since she has just told us a great deal. The poem has already given away its answer, though: "All this -- and more -- if I should tell -- / Would never be believed." Disbelief protects the secret, so she can speak freely and stay loyal. Then she dismisses the reader: "So go your Way -- and I'll go Mine -- / No fear you'll miss the Road." The tone is teasing and a little sharp. The reader's road is the plain, well-marked one, and the speaker's is not.

The form supports this mix of tenderness and mischief. The stanzas are quatrains whose lines alternate between roughly eight and six syllables, close to the rhythm of a hymn or nursery song. That familiar beat suits a poem about bedtime, but Dickinson keeps loosening it. Some rhymes are exact, like "feet" and "Sweet," or "unperceived" and "believed." Others only lean toward each other. "Wind" and "find" look alike on the page but don't sound alike, and "Word" and "Road" share only their final consonant. These slight misfits keep the poem from sounding too neat, as if it were slightly uncertain of its own footing, which fits a poem about things only half seen.

The punctuation does similar work. Dickinson's dashes break the sentences into small pauses, so we hear the speaker hesitating, listening, deciding what to reveal. Her odd capitals ("Murmur," "Hubbub," "Trundle bed," "Nightgowns," "Mine") make ordinary words look like proper names, as though each belongs to a private world with its own rules. Even "Mine" at the end gets this treatment, which gives the speaker's path a little extra dignity.

The poem matters because it shows how much Dickinson could do with a very small space. She wrote in Amherst, Massachusetts, and produced nearly eighteen hundred poems, very few of which appeared in print during her lifetime. A lawn, some trees and a few birds were enough for her. Here the garden becomes a place of secret domestic life, and the poem's real subject turns out to be attention itself: the idea that the world is fuller than we usually notice, and that the person who notices may keep part of it to herself. The final lines refuse to hand the reader a neat explanation, and that refusal is the poem's last joke.

Read also

More by Emily Dickinson

All poems
ContemplativeEmily Dickinson

Too happy Time dissolves itself

Too happy Time dissolves itself And leaves no remnant by -- 'Tis Anguish not a Feather hath Or too much weight to fly --
SadEmily Dickinson

We talked as Girls do --

We talked as Girls do -- Fond, and late -- We speculated fair, on every subject, but the Grave -- Of ours, none affair --