I cannot dance upon my Toes — Poem analysis

I cannot dance upon my Toes -- No Man instructed me -- But oftentimes, among my mind, A Glee possesseth me,

That had I Ballet knowledge -- Would put itself abroad In Pirouette to blanch a Troupe -- Or lay a Prima, mad,

And though I had no Gown of Gauze -- No Ringlet, to my Hair, Nor hopped to Audiences -- like Birds, One Claw upon the Air,

Nor tossed my shape in Eider Balls, Nor rolled on wheels of snow Till I was out of sight, in sound, The House encore me so --

Nor any know I know the Art I mention -- easy -- Here -- Nor any Placard boast me -- It's full as Opera --

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Dickinson begins by admitting a failure: "I cannot dance upon my Toes." She ends by claiming that what goes on inside her is "full as Opera." The poem lives in the gap between those two statements. Its subject is a private joy, a "Glee" that would burst into spectacular dance if only she had the training. Its central idea is that the lack of training, costume and applause does not make the performance any smaller. The real stage is the mind, and by the end, the poem itself.

The opening is plain and a little rueful: "No Man instructed me." What follows is stranger. The Glee arrives "among my mind," an odd phrase that makes the mind sound less like a single thing than a crowded room. It "possesseth" her, a word that sounds old-fashioned and almost religious, as if joy were a visiting spirit. The imagined dance is pure comic exaggeration. A pirouette good enough "to blanch a Troupe" would turn the whole company pale, and it might even "lay a Prima, mad." The poem doesn't say why, but jealousy seems the obvious guess. The speaker is amusingly confident about a skill she says she doesn't have.

The middle stanzas pile up negatives: no gown, no ringlet, not hopping to audiences, not tossing her shape, not rolling. The list is meant to show what she lacks, but it backfires in an interesting way. Each missing prop is so vividly imagined that the reader sees it anyway. The dancer "hopped to Audiences -- like Birds, / One Claw upon the Air" is a lovely, slightly ridiculous image, with the grace of a ballet pose undercut by the word "Claw." The "Eider Balls" suggest soft, downy costume puffs, and the "wheels of snow" suggest a glide so smooth it's almost weightless. Then comes the strangest line: "Till I was out of sight, in sound." The dancer vanishes into the roar of the crowd, and one sense swaps places with another. The capitalised nouns (Gauze, Placard, Troupe, House) also read like props lined up in the wings.

The form is more disciplined than it first looks. The stanzas follow a hymn-like pattern of longer and shorter lines, roughly eight syllables then six, so the beat stays steady and almost sedate. The rhymes are loose. "Hair" and "Air" and "snow" and "so" chime properly, while "abroad" and "mad," and "Here" and "Opera," only echo each other. The first stanza even rhymes "me" with itself. Against this tidy frame, the grammar comes apart. The long "though I had no… Nor… Nor… Nor…" sentence never settles into a clean conclusion, so the syntax seems to spin, and the dashes work like held breaths between leaps. The poem manages a pirouette in its sentences that the speaker says she can't manage on her toes.

The last stanza is where the idea turns. "Nor any know I know the Art / I mention -- easy -- Here --." The key word is "Here." The art is being practised at this moment, on this page, with no audience and no "Placard" to "boast" her. The final line, "It's full as Opera," is flat and understated. Its "It" could mean the Glee, her mind or the poem, and the ambiguity lets all three count. Opera is also an excellent choice: the biggest, loudest, most extravagant art form, set beside a speaker who says she has no stage at all.

The poem matters because it argues for imagination as a complete theatre, and then proves the point by performing. It is also funny, which keeps the claim from sounding solemn or boastful. Dickinson wrote nearly 1,800 poems and had very few published in her lifetime, so it is tempting to read these lines as a comment on a hidden creative life. That is an inference, not something the poem states. Even without it, the effect is clear. By the last line the reader has become the "House," the audience watching a dance that was never danced.

Read also

More by Emily Dickinson

All poems
SadEmily Dickinson

We talked as Girls do --

We talked as Girls do -- Fond, and late -- We speculated fair, on every subject, but the Grave -- Of ours, none affair --
ContemplativeEmily Dickinson

Yesterday is History,

Yesterday is History, 'Tis so far away -- Yesterday is Poetry -- 'Tis Philosophy --
SadEmily Dickinson

I never lost as much but twice

I never lost as much but twice, And that was in the sod. Twice have I stood a beggar Before the door of God!