Where She Told Her Love — Poem analysis

John ClareRomantic

I saw her crop a rose Right early in the day, And I went to kiss the place Where she broke the rose away And I saw the patten rings Where she oer the stile had gone, And I love all other things Her bright eyes look upon. If she looks upon the hedge or up the leafing tree, The whitethorn or the brown oak are made dearer things to me.

I have a pleasant hill Which I sit upon for hours, Where she cropt some sprigs of thyme And other little flowers; And she muttered as she did it As does beauty in a dream, And I loved her when she hid it On her breast, so like to cream,

Near the brown mole on her neck that to me a diamond shone Then my eye was like to fire, and my heart was like to stone.

There is a small green place Where cowslips early curled, Which on Sabbath day I trace, The dearest in the world. A little oak spreads oer it, And throws a shadow round, A green sward close before it, The greenest ever found:

There is not a woodland nigh nor is there a green grove, Yet stood the fair maid nigh me and told me all her love.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Most love poems hurry towards the beloved's face. Clare's keeps circling the ground she has walked on. In the first stanza the speaker watches a girl pick a rose early in the morning. He then goes to kiss the spot where the stem was snapped, and a few lines later he is studying the ring-shaped prints of her pattens, the raised overshoes worn to keep feet clear of mud, beside the stile she crossed. She hardly appears herself. What we get are her traces. The central idea is that love rearranges the world. If she looks at the hedge or the leafing tree, "the whitethorn or the brown oak are made dearer things to me." Plain hedgerow becomes precious because her eyes rested on it.

That devotion hardens into ritual. The speaker sits "for hours" on the hill where she cropped thyme, and on the Sabbath he goes to "trace" the green place where the cowslips grow, "the dearest in the world." The day he picks suggests a private shrine set against the church, though that is an inference from the text rather than something it says. "Trace" works twice, meaning to walk over a spot and to follow an outline, as if he were retracing her steps.

The shape of each stanza helps the feeling along. Eight short lines of about three beats, with a loose ballad lilt, are followed by a long couplet of fourteen syllables or so. The short lines move like a song, and in the first stanza they rhyme *day/away*, *rings/things*, *gone/upon*, while "rose" and "place" hang unanswered. The long lines then stretch out, as if the speaker has to let out a breath. The pattern repeats three times, and each couplet is where the stanza's emotion lands.

The second couplet is the most startling. The girl hides the thyme "on her breast, so like to cream," soft and homely, but then comes "the brown mole on her neck that to me a diamond shone." The poem's only jewel is a mole on a country girl's neck, and it has been made precious by the same transforming eye that turned the oak dear. The speaker's reaction is a pair of hard, contradictory images: "my eye was like to fire, and my heart was like to stone." Desire burns and the body goes rigid, a believable picture of a young man too overwhelmed to move.

The third stanza narrows to colour and repetition. Green is stacked up in "small green place," "green sward," "the greenest ever found," "green grove," with a simplicity close to a child's insistence. The rhyme even uses the same word twice, with "spreads oer it" and "before it" sitting in rhyming positions. That artlessness suits the speaker, who is not trying to be clever. The last couplet then pulls back from grandeur: "There is not a woodland nigh nor is there a green grove." The place is modest, a single little oak. Then comes "Yet," and the title's promise is finally kept. The fair maid "told me all her love." The line is reported, not quoted, so we never hear her words. Everything before it, the rose, the thyme, the stile, begins to look like a long approach to this one sentence. Even the rhyme *grove/love* looks stronger on the page than it sounds in modern speech, which gives the ending a slightly unpolished, spoken feel.

The poem's power comes from its diction as much as its feeling. Words like "cropt," "oer," "nigh" and "patten" belong to the countryside rather than the drawing room. Clare was a farm labourer's son from rural Northamptonshire, and he wrote as a countryman. Here the fields are the whole vocabulary of love, with no borrowed classical garlands. Its lasting interest lies in how it defines love as attention. The speaker never lists her virtues. He keeps noticing what she touched and where she stood, and in doing so he turns a small patch of green into the dearest place in the world.

Read also

More by John Clare

All poems
CheerfulJohn Clare

Insects

These tiny loiterers on the barley's beard, And happy units of a numerous herd Of playfellows, the laughing Summer brings, Mocking the sunshine in their glittering wings,
SadJohn Clare

To Anna Three Years Old

My Anna, summer laughs in mirth, And we will of the party be, And leave the crickets in the hearth For green fields' merry minstrelsy.
CheerfulJohn Clare

The Skylark

Above the russet clods the corn is seen Sprouting its spiry points of tender green, Where squats the hare, to terrors wide awake, Like some brown clod the harrows failed to break.