In Memoriam A. H. H.: 82. I wage not any feud with death — Poem analysis

I wage not any feud with Death For changes wrought on form and face; No lower life that earth's embrace May breed with him, can fright my faith. Eternal process moving on, From state to state the spirit walks; And these are but the shatter'd stalks, Or ruin'd chrysalis of one. Nor blame I Death, because he bare The use of virtue out of earth: I know transplanted human worth Will bloom to profit, otherwhere.

For this alone on Death I wreak The wrath that garners in my heart; He put our lives so far apart We cannot hear each other speak.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Most elegies rage at death wholesale. Tennyson's section 82 does something more unusual: it lists what he forgives Death for, then names the one thing he cannot. The first twelve lines are built from refusals, "I wage not any feud" and "Nor blame I Death", and the speaker sounds almost like a lawyer conceding point after point. Only in the last four lines does "I" give way to "our", and the real grievance arrives.

The first thing he forgives is physical decay. Death changes "form and face", and the grave's "embrace" may "breed" lower life from the body, but none of it can "fright my faith." To make peace with this, the speaker turns to images of growth. The body becomes "shatter'd stalks", the dry stems left after harvest, or the "ruin'd chrysalis" of a butterfly that has already flown. The two pictures come from different worlds, one from the field and one from insect life, but they make the same argument: don't mistake the leftover for the living thing. "From state to state the spirit walks" is calm and ordinary, as if dying were one stage of a journey.

His second concession is that Death "bare / The use of virtue out of earth". Here "bare" is an old form of "bore", meaning carried off. The loss is not just of a person but of goodness that was useful in the world. Tennyson answers in garden language again: "transplanted human worth / Will bloom to profit, otherwhere." Transplanting is deliberate and careful, what a gardener does to give a plant better ground. The archaic "otherwhere" is vague, though. The speaker is confident that such a place exists but cannot say where, and the word's strangeness quietly admits this.

Then comes the turn: "For this alone". The word "alone" carries the weight of the whole poem, because everything before it is cleared away to isolate this single charge. The wrath "garners in my heart", and "garner" is a harvest verb meaning to gather grain into storage. After the stalks and blooms, anger turns out to be a crop too, something that keeps accumulating. "Wreak" is the most violent word in the poem, and it rhymes with "speak". Vengeance and the lost voice are bound together by sound. The final line, "We cannot hear each other speak", is plain and almost entirely one-syllable. It has no metaphor and no consolation. Faith can promise that worth will bloom elsewhere, but it cannot supply a voice.

The form reinforces this restraint. Each quatrain is iambic tetrameter rhymed *abba*, with the outer rhymes enclosing the inner pair. This is the stanza that gives *In Memoriam* its distinctive sound. Here it creates a feeling of circling back. The first stanza opens on "Death" and closes on "faith", two words forced into partnership by rhyme. The last stanza does the same with "wreak" and "speak". The steady beat never lurches, so the few moments where feeling pushes through stand out. Typographically, three quatrains run together and the fourth stands apart, like a postscript that the speaker could not leave unsaid.

The title's initials point to Arthur Henry Hallam, the friend whose death the sequence mourns. Section 82 matters because it refuses an easy choice between belief and grief. Intellectually, the speaker holds that nothing essential is destroyed. Emotionally, he cannot get past the silence. Tennyson does not let the first cancel the second, and that honesty is why the poem still feels true. A reader might also take from it that a controlled, carefully argued poem can hold more pain than an outburst, because the anger only appears once everything else has been reasoned away.

Read also

More by Lord Alfred Tennyson

All poems
CheerfulLord Alfred Tennyson

Move Eastward, Happy Earth

Move eastward, happy earth, and leave Yon orange sunset waning slow: From fringes of the faded eve, O, happy planet, eastward go:
CheerfulLord Alfred Tennyson

Spring

Birds' love and birds' song Flying here and there, Birds' songand birds' love And you with gold for hair!