Fragment on Keats — Poem analysis

ON KEATS, WHO DESIRED THAT ON HIS TOMB SHOULD BE INSCRIBED--

'Here lieth One whose name was writ on water. But, ere the breath that could erase it blew, Death, in remorse for that fell slaughter, Death, the immortalizing winter, flew Athwart the stream,--and time's printless torrent grew A scroll of crystal, blazoning the name Of Adonais!

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Keats wanted a tomb that carried no name, only a sentence about the lack of one: "Here lieth One whose name was writ on water." Shelley's fragment, as its headnote explains, takes that wish and answers it in seven lines by turning the water to ice.

The opening line is quoted, humble and resigned. Water holds no impression, so a name written on it is already vanishing. Shelley adds a threat to the image: "ere the breath that could erase it blew." The name has been written, but the erasing breath has not yet arrived. The poem never says what this breath is. It could be a wind rippling the surface, or time, or oblivion itself. That vagueness makes the danger feel larger.

The rescue comes from the least likely source. Death appears as a killer with a conscience, acting "in remorse for that fell slaughter." "Fell" is used in its old sense of cruel and deadly, and "slaughter" is a brutal word for a young man's death. Then the poem repeats the word, "Death, the immortalizing winter," and the repetition changes its meaning. Death is renamed as the force that gives permanence. "Immortalizing winter" is a paradox, since winter is the season of dying, yet here its cold is what saves. Death is made to undo some of its own harm.

The sound of the verse helps the action along. The rhymes "blew," "flew" and "grew" fall on three lines out of five, and each is a short verb of movement or change. "Flew" carries Death across the river, and "Athwart the stream" suggests one sweeping motion. Then comes the longest line, "and time's printless torrent grew." Its stresses pile up and jostle, as if the rush of time can hardly be fitted into the metre. The torrent is fast and leaves no footprints, which is exactly Keats's problem: nothing it touches is recorded. But the verb is "grew," a slow, quiet word, and the torrent becomes something that grows into a fixed shape.

That shape is "a scroll of crystal, blazoning the name." Shelley completes his writing metaphor here. Water was a hopeless page, but ice is a page that keeps what is written on it. "Blazoning" comes from heraldry and means to display or proclaim, so the name is announced rather than merely kept. Crystal is also clear, so the name is preserved without being hidden.

The form hints at larger ambitions. The rhyme scheme, ABABB, recalls the opening of the Spenserian stanza, which Shelley used in *Adonais*, his elegy for Keats. But the stanza here never completes itself. "Name" ends the sixth line and "Adonais" the seventh, and neither is answered by a rhyme. The opening quotation mark is also never closed in the text we have. The poem simply stops, which is what a fragment does. Yet it stops on the name, and the last thing the reader sees is the very thing the poem says has been saved.

The name that is saved is also worth noticing. The verse never says "Keats," which appears only in the title and headnote. What the crystal scroll displays is "Adonais," the name Shelley gave Keats in his elegy. Keats imagined a name written in water, and Shelley replaces it with a mythic one that belongs to poetry. This can be read as a quiet correction of Keats's modesty. The man may have thought himself forgotten, but the poem insists he is not.

The fragment is significant because it packs the central consolation of elegy into a single extended image. Death takes the poet and also fixes his name where time cannot wash it away. It is a small, unfinished piece, but the reversal at its centre, water becoming ice and loss becoming monument, is complete.

Read also

More by Percy Bysshe Shelley

All poems
RomanticPercy Bysshe Shelley

Music

I pant for the music which is divine, My heart in its thirst is a dying flower; Pour forth the sound like enchanted wine, Loosen the notes in a silver shower;
RomanticPercy Bysshe Shelley

To Mary --

O Mary dear, that you were here With your brown eyes bright and clear. And your sweet voice, like a bird Singing love to its lone mate
SadPercy Bysshe Shelley

Autumn: A Dirge

The warm sun is failing, the bleak wind is wailing, The bare boughs are sighing, the pale flowers are dying, And the Year On the earth her death-bed, in a shroud of leaves dead,