In heaven — Poem analysis

Stephen CraneContemplative

In heaven, Some little blades of grass Stood before God. "What did you do?" Then all save one of the little blades Began eagerly to relate The merits of their lives. This one stayed a small way behind, Ashamed. Presently, God said, "And what did you do?" The little blade answered, "Oh my Lord, Memory is bitter to me, For, if I did good deeds, I know not of them." Then God, in all His splendor, Arose from His throne. "Oh, best little blade of grass!" He said.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Picture a classroom where every hand shoots up except one. Stephen Crane stages that scene in heaven, with blades of grass lined up before God and asked to account for themselves. Nearly all of them answer "eagerly," each "relating the merits of their lives" like pupils reciting a list of achievements. Only one hangs back, ashamed, and it is this one that God singles out at the end. The idea is quietly radical: real goodness may be the kind that never notices itself, and the moment we can itemise our virtues, we may already have spent them.

The poem is built like a very short parable, and Crane is careful about how it unfolds. There is no rhyme and no regular beat. The lines are short and uneven, and they run as plainly as speech. That plainness suits a story about modesty, because nothing in the verse shows off. Crane does let the line length work for him, though. "Ashamed." sits alone on its own line, a single word that seems to shrink into the margin just as the blade shrinks behind the others. By contrast, the boasting is stretched across the longer lines "Began eagerly to relate / The merits of their lives," where the sentence itself seems to go on talking. The diction is also faintly biblical. "Presently," "Arose" and "Oh my Lord" give the little scene the feel of old scripture without any heavy decoration.

The choice of grass is the poem's best stroke. Grass is the humblest thing in a landscape: countless, identical, trodden on, and cut down without ceremony. Biblical writing sometimes uses grass as an image of how brief and ordinary human life is, and Crane seems to lean on that echo. Judging by the imagery, these blades stand for ordinary people, and the repeated word "little" (the "little blades," the "little blade," the "best little blade") keeps their smallness in front of us. By the last line, though, "little" sounds affectionate rather than dismissive.

The key words come from the language of accounting. "Merits" and "what did you do?" suggest a ledger, as if heaven were an office where deeds are tallied. The honest blade accepts that framework and then quietly breaks it. "Memory is bitter to me, / For, if I did good deeds, / I know not of them." The small word "if" matters here. The blade does not claim to have done nothing. It simply cannot see its own goodness, and its bitterness comes from looking back and finding no proof to offer. Its shame is a kind of conscientiousness, the opposite of the others' pride.

Then comes the reversal. "God, in all His splendor, / Arose from His throne." Crane puts the grandest figure imaginable next to the smallest, and it is God who moves. Rising is a gesture of respect, and here the hierarchy tips over. The blade's own words are "Oh my Lord," and God answers with "Oh, best little blade of grass!" He echoes that opening "Oh," and it becomes the poem's only exclamation, so the whole quiet poem breaks into warmth at its final line. God does not argue with the blade or list its deeds on its behalf. The praise is simply given.

The poem's significance lies in how neatly it overturns the usual picture of judgement. We expect a final reckoning to reward the best résumé, but Crane suggests that the eager self-description of the many is exactly what disqualifies them. The echo of the teaching that charity should be done without announcing it feels deliberate, though Crane never states it. There is also a gentle irony the poem leaves open. The blade is called best precisely because it does not know it, so the compliment cannot please it without changing it. Praise would turn the blade into one of the others.

For a reader today, the poem can feel uncomfortably close to home. We live among résumés, ranked results and public displays of virtue. In a dozen plain lines, Crane asks what happens to goodness once it starts looking for an audience, and he answers with a small, ashamed blade of grass standing a little way behind everyone else.

Read also

More by Stephen Crane

All poems
DreamyStephen Crane

Ay, workman, make me a dream,

Ay, workman, make me a dream, A dream for my love. Cunningly weave sunlight, Breezes, and flowers.
ContemplativeStephen Crane

A man went before a strange God

A man went before a strange God -- The God of many men, sadly wise. And the deity thundered loudly, Fat with rage, and puffing.
ContemplativeStephen Crane

In a lonely place,

In a lonely place, I encountered a sage Who sat, all still, Regarding a newspaper.