The speaker, Carl Hamblin, is a newspaper editor in Spoon River who was tarred and feathered after his press was wrecked. His crime was printing an allegory on the day the Chicago anarchists were hanged. In that allegory, Justice appears as a beautiful blindfolded woman holding a sword and scales. She strikes children, laborers, and outcasts while the rich toss gold into her scales and dodge the blade. A black-robed man declares that she is “no respecter of persons,” but a young radical rips off the blindfold. Beneath it, her eyes are rotted, oozing, and mad, and the crowd finally sees why she wore it.
Hamblin’s voice is bitter and unrepentant; he clearly believes the allegory told the truth. The mood is grim and nightmarish, blending political anger with disgust at a justice system that hides its corruption behind a mask of impartiality.