A Question — Summary

I asked if I got sick and died, would you With my black funeral go walking too, If you’d stand close to hear them talk or pray While I’m let down in that steep bank of clay. And, No, you said, for if you saw a crew Of living idiots pressing round that new Oak coffin--they alive, I dead beneath That board--you’d rave and rend them with your teeth.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

A speaker asks his beloved whether she would walk with his funeral and stand nearby while he is lowered into the clay grave. Her answer is no—not from coldness, but because the sight of “living idiots” crowding around his coffin would enrage her so much that she would tear them with her teeth.

That reply turns a conventional question about mourning into something raw and possessive. The speaker seems to be testing her devotion, but her response refuses social ritual entirely. Grief here is not quiet or pious; it is fierce, almost animal. The mood is macabre and intense, mixing death with violent love. Rather than finding comfort in ceremony, the beloved can only fixate on the one person she would lose, and the living mourners become unbearable.

Read also

More by J. M. Synge

All poems
CheerfulJ. M. Synge

In May

In a nook That opened south, You and I Lay mouth to mouth.
RomanticJ. M. Synge

Dread

Beside a chapel I’d a room looked down, Where all the women from the farms and town, On Holy-days and Sundays used to pass To marriages, and christenings, and to Mass.
SadJ. M. Synge

To the Oaks of Glencree

My arms are round you, and I lean Against you, while the lark Sings over us, and golden lights, and green Shadows are on your bark.