I Will Ask — Summary

John FreemanContemplative

I will ask primrose and violet to spend for you Their smell and hue, And the bold, trembling anemone awhile to spare Her flowers starry fair; Or the flushed wild apple and yet sweeter thorn Their sweetness to keep Longer than any fire-bosomed flower born Between midnight and midnight deep.

And I will take celandine, nettle and parsley, white In its own green light, Or milkwort and sorrel, thyme, harebell and meadowsweet Lifting at your feet, And ivy blossom beloved of soft bees; I will take The loveliest-- The seeding grasses that bend with the winds, and shake Though the winds are at rest.

"For me?" you will ask. "Yes! surely they wave for you Their smell and hue, And you away all that is rare were so much less By your missed happiness." Yet I know grass and weed, ivy and apple and thorn Their whole sweet would keep Though in Eden no human spirit on a shining morn Had awaked from sleep.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

The speaker in “I Will Ask” imagines gathering wildflowers, blossoms, and seeding grasses to offer their color and scent to someone dear. He names them tenderly—primrose, violet, anemone, hawthorn, celandine, thyme—and says he will ask them to hold their sweetness longer for this person’s sake. The gesture feels intimate and full of affection: he wants the natural world to seem to welcome the beloved, as if waving and blooming just for her.

But the final stanza shifts. The speaker admits that these plants would keep their whole sweetness even if no human being had ever woken in Eden to notice them. That quiet recognition doesn’t undo the loving offer; it adds a humbling, slightly wistful note. The mood is lush and tender, yet clear-eyed about nature’s independence from human joy.

Read also

More by John Freeman

All poems
CheerfulJohn Freeman

The Silvery One

Clear from the deep sky pours the moon Her silver on the heavy dark; The small stars blink. Against the moon the maple bough
ContemplativeJohn Freeman

Listening

There is a place of grass With daisies like white pools, Or shining islands in a sea Of brightening waves.
CheerfulJohn Freeman

Happiness

I have found happiness who looked not for it. There was a green fresh hedge, And willows by the river side, And whistling sedge.