Katherine Mansfield sets two children side by side as playful opposites. One is a messy, outdoor-loving girl in half-soled boots who splashes puddles, stains her hands black as ink, loses hair ribbons, and kisses her mother loudly. The other is a neat, quiet girl in patent-leather slippers who stays indoors, keeps her hands white as snow, sews, and offers only a polite cheek at morning and night.
The speaker clearly enjoys both temperaments. The poem is full of affectionate amusement rather than scolding. It celebrates the boisterous child’s warmth—her laughing face is like a scented summer rose—while also accepting the prim child, not as a decorative ornament but as a real daughter to hold. The mood is light, tender, and a little playful, as if a parent is smiling at the differences between two beloved children.