Others — Poem analysis

so many hearts singe with my feelings so many streets flats nations bistros prairies hold my frenzies hopes

here fields and bungalows and dogs on chains but there's one sky & sun one subtle puppetry

I'd like my words to enter prairie rooms ship holds to murmur some ecstatic forest vision find kin in prisoners in solitude crowds each with his flame

so many flames at once would burn up burdens ancient city walls neural fortresses

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Anne Scott Musil's «Others» opens with a claim that sounds almost boastful and closes with a wish that sounds almost shy. The speaker announces that "so many hearts singe / with my feelings," then spends the remaining lines working out what that connection is for. Her answer is that it might help people break out of the walls that confine them.

The title promises a poem about other people, yet the first stanza is crowded with "my" and "my / frenzies hopes." The usual direction of empathy is reversed. The speaker does not feel for strangers. She imagines strangers feeling her. The verb "singe" is a precise choice. It is not "burn" and not "warm," but the scorching edge of fire, a feeling that spreads by contact and leaves a mark. The list that follows, "so many streets flats nations / bistros prairies," has no commas, so the scale slides from a single street to whole countries and from a café table to open grassland. The reader cannot tell where one item ends and the next begins, which fits the idea that boundaries mean little here. Even the last line, "frenzies hopes," drops the "and," as if the two states were too tangled to separate.

The second stanza pulls the camera back to the ordinary: "fields and bungalows / and dogs on chains." The details are small, fenced and domestic, and the chained dogs quietly prepare for the prisoners who arrive later. Then comes the stanza's turn: "but there's one sky & sun one / subtle puppetry." The ampersand is the poem's only symbol, and it welds sky and sun into a single thing. The second "one" hangs at the end of the line, so it can attach to what came before or to "puppetry" after it. "Puppetry" is deliberately unsettling. If something pulls strings beneath a shared sky, we are all moved by the same hidden hands. The poem never says whether that is comforting or sinister.

Only the third stanza states a desire, and it does so in the conditional: "I'd like my words to enter." Words that "enter" are either welcome guests or trespassers. They go into "prairie rooms ship holds," where open land shrinks to rooms and a ship's hold adds darkness and enclosure. What they carry is a paradox: they "murmur some ecstatic / forest vision." Murmuring is quiet and ecstasy is loud, and the vague "some" admits the speaker cannot quite name what she wants to pass on. The syntax then slips in a productive way. In "find kin in prisoners / in solitude crowds each with / his flame," the phrase "in solitude crowds" can mean people alone and people in crowds, or crowds that are themselves solitary. Either way, each person carries a private flame. "Kin" is the poem's answer to its title, since the others become family. "Flame" also links back to "singe" and prepares the final image.

That image is the fourth stanza's fire. It opens with the same "so many" that began the poem, so hearts being singed become flames burning together: "so many flames at once / would burn up burdens." The heavy, thudding b-sounds make the line feel weighted before it destroys the weight. Then the targets widen from "ancient city walls" to "neural fortresses," from stone defences to ones inside the skull. The clinical word "neural" jars against the archaic ones, as if modern anxiety were just the latest siege architecture. Notice the verb, too: "would." The poem ends in the conditional, and its last words name the obstacle, not the freedom beyond it.

The form supports this reaching. There is no rhyme and no punctuation, and the stanzas run five, four, seven and four lines. The lines break on incomplete words such as "my," "one," "some" and "each with," so the reader keeps leaning forward to the next line for the sense, in a small enactment of the speaker's own stretching toward other people.

The poem's significance lies in its honesty about that stretch. It risks presumption, since the speaker assumes everyone's heart carries her feelings, but it corrects itself by moving from claiming to seeking kinship. In twenty spare lines it makes a case for what poetry might do: not a promise that words will topple walls, but the hope that enough small flames, lit at once, could.

Read also

More by Anne Scott Musil

All poems
ContemplativeAnne Scott Musil

Swimming

in the littered kitchen rubbing dirty pots and hot i think of swimming still cold dark-green water
DreamyAnne Scott Musil

Illusion

the dream castle the exotic land expand to ordinary space as you walk into them almost bored the magic gone with
ContemplativeAnne Scott Musil

Hands

sometimes the hands know best where the switch is limbs know which way to turn