Public Affairs — Summary

what's all the shouting about, the man wanted to know; i couldn't tell him. It wasn't, even, as if there weren't anything to shout about, there was plenty, i can tell you. but how could i translate successfully enough? to tell him just what the shouting was about.

so finally, since he kept insisting, i told him all, how the colts had deserted their sacred oath, and more important, the border guard, and

alexander, big man, halfway into india.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

A man asks the speaker what all the shouting is about, and the speaker finds he can't answer. There is plenty to shout about, he insists, but he doesn't know how to put it into words the man would understand. The trouble isn't a lack of causes. It's the gap between the noise of public life and any plain explanation of it.

When the man keeps pressing, the speaker finally gives in and tells him "all." What follows is an odd jumble: colts who broke a sacred oath, a border guard, and then Alexander, "big man, halfway into india." The list slides from the small to the grand, and the explanation collapses into something half-mythic and half-absurd. The poem seems to suggest that big public quarrels, once you try to explain them, sound strange and disconnected.

The mood is dry and wry. The speaker sounds tired, a little amused, and quietly skeptical about how much any of this noise means.

Read also

More by Joel Oppenheimer

All poems
RomanticJoel Oppenheimer

Where Are My Glasses

wild creatures, blinded by passion, tearing down the pillars, the
CheerfulJoel Oppenheimer

The Riddle

what's gray and comes in quarts is an elephant or my brain; what loves or walks slowly in the land is an elephant gray
DreamyJoel Oppenheimer

The Title Repeats

You'RE INTO IT ALREADY THIRTYthree years deep while the dawn comes up like two bulls one young one old walking down