The Lesser — Poem analysis

Cynthia Arafa22/4/2010Romantic

He’s worse than a placebo genetically enhanced to make my heart race, make adrenalin rush; engrave feelings so Raw I can’t breathe. In one slight stroke all privy revealed all truths Known. And I love it. In one heart-wrenching movement exhilaration overtakes all feeling. The air would feel stuffy, entwined in soft threads of intensity, Hyperventilation is to be expected. Loss of palpable consciousness Detachment from the rest of the world. Confusion Dazedness. Defiance. Love.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Love, in Cynthia Arafa's "The Lesser," arrives like a drug with a long list of side effects, and the speaker, against all medical sense, asks for more. The opening line sets the terms: "He's worse than a placebo." A placebo is a harmless sham, so being "worse" than one is a twist. It means he is the opposite of inert: real, potent and "genetically enhanced" to "make my heart race" and "make adrenalin rush." We learn nothing about his looks or his words. He is described entirely by his dosage.

That pharmaceutical logic runs through the whole poem. By the closing lines the language has become a symptom chart: "Hyperventilation / is to be expected," "Loss of palpable consciousness," "Confusion / Dazedness." The phrase "is to be expected" belongs to the small print of a leaflet, not to a love poem, and the coldness is deliberate. Notice what happens to the speaker's voice. Early on it is intensely personal: "I can't breathe," "And I love it." By the end the "I" has disappeared and the grammar has shrunk to fragments. The form acts out the "Detachment from the rest of the world" that the poem names. The speaker is so overtaken that they can no longer say what is happening to them in a full sentence.

There is no rhyme and no steady metre. This is free verse, and its rhythm comes from line length and breath. The lines are short and the punctuation sparse, so the reader has little room to pause, which suits a speaker who cannot breathe. The odd capitals work like spikes on a monitor. "Raw" is stranded on its own line after "engrave feelings so," and "Known" is left alone at the end of "all truths." Both words are about exposure. The syntax also bends at that moment: "all privy revealed" stretches "privy" into a noun-like role, as if ordinary grammar can't keep up with how much has been uncovered. The verb "engrave" is worth a look too. It suggests something permanent and slightly violent, cut into the speaker rather than merely felt.

The imagery plays hard against soft. "In one slight stroke" and "In one heart-wrenching movement" echo each other, but "slight" and "heart-wrenching" pull in opposite directions: a tiny gesture, an enormous effect. The poem never says whether the stroke is a touch, a glance or a word, and that vagueness lets any small moment stand for it. "Stroke" also has a medical meaning, and the fainting-away of "Loss of palpable consciousness" may be meant to sit close to it, though the poem doesn't insist. Then the tone changes: "The air would feel stuffy, / entwined in soft threads of intensity." After the violence of "engrave" and "wrenching," the threads are gentle, even cosy. Calling the air "stuffy" is a plain, almost domestic word for something overwhelming. It makes the feeling physical, like a room too warm to think in. The "would" adds to the clinical distance, as if the speaker were describing a typical case rather than their own.

The ending is the most carefully built part. Five one-word lines follow in quick succession: "Confusion / Dazedness. / Defiance. / Love." The first two are things that happen to the speaker. "Defiance" is something the speaker does, though the poem doesn't say against whom. The title may offer a clue. "The Lesser" could point to a "lesser" choice or a lesser evil, which would make the defiance a refusal of someone's judgement, but that is an inference, since the poem never explains its title. "Love" comes last and alone, like a diagnosis after the symptoms, or the real cause behind them.

What makes the poem worth reading is that it takes an old idea, being sick with love, and commits to it completely. Because the clinical register never lets up, the emotion feels more surprising and more honest. The speaker calls him "worse" and also says "I love it," and the poem doesn't try to settle that contradiction. It leaves us with the symptoms and one final word.

Read also

More by Cynthia Arafa

All poems
ContemplativeCynthia Arafa

Painted Pictures

There's a truth in a painted picture of grass, as it's sways aside to reveal secrets. In poppies that