Without — Poem analysis

Dave BontaCheerful

Because the electric guitar had no hole, in the middle of a song the old bluesman lowered his mouth to it & plucked the strings with his gold- capped teeth.

Because the sawhorse had no head, it didn’t know which way to run when a plank saddled it, & it let the saw whinny for both of them.

Because the hermit had no wife, he bought a clock with a loud tick & wound it faithfully once a week with a little brass key.

Because the trailer had no cellar, its inhabitants rushed out & threw themselves into a ditch when the tornado came howling its one blue note.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Four times the poem says "Because," and four times what follows sounds like logic but behaves like a tall tale. A guitar with no hole, a sawhorse with no head, a hermit with no wife, a trailer with no cellar: each lack is announced in the first line of a five-line stanza, and the next four lines show what the world does about it. The answer is always a makeshift substitute. The central idea is that absence is not simply emptiness. It is pressure, and it pushes things into invention that can be funny, tender or frightening.

The first stanza sets the pattern. An electric guitar has no sound hole, unlike an acoustic one, so the old bluesman lowers his mouth to it and plucks the strings "with his gold- / capped teeth." The line break splits the word "gold-capped" in two, so the gap sits inside the phrase, as if the form itself were doing without. The bluesman is the poem's ideal figure, someone who turns a limitation into a showpiece.

The sawhorse stanza is the most playful. Having no head, the sawhorse "didn't know which way to run," a joke that treats a trestle as a horse. Once a plank "saddles" it, the pun grows, and the saw "whinny" speaks for it. The image is also accurate, since a saw's rasping really does sound a little like a whinny. Here the substitute voice is borrowed from another object, and the phrase "for both of them" makes the two tools a pair.

Then the tone cools. The hermit buys "a clock / with a loud tick" and winds it "faithfully once a week / with a little brass key." "Faithfully" is a marriage word, and the weekly winding is a domestic duty, so the clock becomes a spouse in everything but name. The hard k sounds of "tick," "clock" and "key" make the lines click along like the machine. The poem never says the hermit is lonely, but judging by the care in that "little brass key," the joke has a sad edge.

The last stanza drops the comedy. The trailer's inhabitants "rushed out / & threw themselves into a ditch," and the verbs are panicky and physical. A cellar would have been a refuge, but the ditch is a poor improvisation, and nothing in the poem suggests it is enough. The trailer also hints at a precarious, modest way of living, though that is an inference from one image. The tornado arrives "howling / its one blue note," which brings the poem back to the music of its opening. A blue note is a bent, aching note in the blues, and "one" makes the sound relentless. In this stanza the improvised music belongs to the storm, and the people are the ones left without. The title also carries an older meaning of "outside," which is where the trailer's inhabitants end up.

Formally, the poem is free verse with no rhyme and no fixed line length, though a few sounds echo, as in "hole," "old" and "gold." Its music comes from repetition. The same opening formula in every stanza makes the poem feel like a set of fables or a blues lyric, with the same chord struck four times. Each stanza lands on a short last line, such as "capped teeth," "for both of them," "with a little brass key," and "its one blue note." These work like punchlines and also like small closing chords. The ampersands and plain diction keep the voice casual, like a storyteller who doesn't want to seem to be teaching anything.

That restraint is what makes the poem worth reading. It never states a moral. It lines up four images and lets us feel the range of "making do," from art (the bluesman) to comfort (the clock) to bare survival (the ditch). The poem is built the same way as its subjects. Without rhyme, without explanation, it makes music out of plain speech and small things, and it suggests that what a person lacks can shape what they make.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss