Landfall — Poem analysis

that one English word in Philippine news reports about Guiuan where Magellan landed in 1521 where the Americans made their first beachhead in World War II in the swirl of Tagalog I don’t understand that word keeps floating to the surface landfall where floors shook where roofs blew off where concrete columns toppled where wind gusts reached 195 miles per hour where a 13-foot wall of water swept ashore landfall where the eye took a brief calm sightless look & moved on where a stone church was flattened landfall where “100 percent of all structures were damaged” where evacuation centers collapsed where 47,000 souls had been living land fall

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Dave Bonta's speaker is listening to news from the Philippines in a language he can't follow, and one word keeps rising out of it: "landfall." The poem takes that single English term, the kind of word weather reporters use without thinking, and holds it up until it starts to look strange. By the end it has split in two, and the poem has said something about distance, language and what it means to hear about a disaster rather than live through it.

The poem never names the storm. It names a place, Guiuan, and then piles up what happened there. Its central idea is that a word built to describe an event cannot hold what the event did. "Landfall" is neutral and almost tidy, a point on a forecast map. Around it the poem places broken floors, roofs, columns and a stone church.

The structure does a lot of this work. There is no rhyme and almost no punctuation, only the quotation marks and an ampersand. The lines are short, and nearly all of them open with "where," so the poem reads like a list that keeps being extended. The first two "where" lines carry history: Magellan arriving in 1521, then the Americans making a beachhead in World War II. Both are arrivals from the sea, and the word "landfall" fits them in a different sense, meaning the first sight of land after a voyage, a moment of relief or conquest. Then the same "where" turns to ruin, and the old meaning of the word gives way to a darker one. Guiuan becomes a place where people keep arriving, and the latest arrival is the worst.

The sound of the middle section is worth hearing aloud. "Where concrete columns toppled" has hard, heavy consonants. "Wind gusts reached 195 miles per hour" and "a 13-foot wall of water" lean on the breathy "w," which sounds like the wind itself. The numbers matter too. They are exact, in the flat voice of a report, and they sit next to plain verbs like "shook," "blew off" and "swept." The poem keeps the facts blunt and lets them do the damage.

The strangest image is the eye of the storm: "the eye took a brief calm / sightless look & moved on." The line break leaves the phrase slightly ambiguous, so "calm" and "sightless" lean against each other. The eye has no sight, which makes the storm feel blind and indifferent as well as terrifying. A pause in which nothing sees is more unsettling than rage would be.

The poem's most human moment comes near the end. The quoted statistic, "100 percent / of all structures were damaged," is broken across a line as though even the speaker hesitates over such a total. Then come "evacuation centers collapsed," where shelter itself fails, and the number "47,000 souls." The word "souls" shifts the register from bureaucratic to nearly spiritual. The past perfect, "had been living," puts those lives at a distance, as if they have already been taken out of the present tense.

Then comes the final move: "land / fall." The compound word is pulled apart so that each half can be read separately. Land falls. The ground that Magellan reached, the beach the Americans took, the earth that was supposed to be the safe place at the end of a voyage, gives way. Splitting the word also splits the news-report meaning from the physical one, and the reader suddenly sees what the word has been hiding.

Earlier, the speaker describes his hearing as a "swirl of Tagalog I don't understand," and "swirl" is also what a storm does, so his confusion and the storm are quietly linked. The word that "keeps floating to the surface" behaves like debris in floodwater. His one foothold is a cold technical term, which suggests how media can give us a word without giving us the experience.

That is the poem's significance. It is honest about the limits of the listener's position and does not pretend to be inside the disaster. Instead it shows the gap between a word and its consequences and lets the reader feel that gap closing, line by line, until the word breaks.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Fairy Bells

Prosartes lanuginosa Their ringing isn’t obvious; you need the ear of an anchorite to find them.
CheerfulDave Bonta

Homunculus

Within my mind a mind I long to tame— a left boy, a little Hercules, the king of ham.