Harbingers — Poem analysis

Dave BontaAnxious

After months under snow, last autumn’s leaves barely stir in the wind,

pressed flat as ears to the forest floor. Surely they know what’s coming.

Stones lie askew. Whatever is beneath them shows no sign of resting in peace.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

A harbinger is supposed to be good news: the first robin, the first crocus, a sign that the hard season is ending. Dave Bonta's poem keeps the word only in its title and then lets it curdle. Nothing in the three short stanzas is cheerful. The snow has gone, and what it uncovers is a scene of listening, tension and unrest. The central idea is that the turning of the year may not be a simple comfort. Renewal, the poem hints, is also an upheaval, and the ground seems to know it before we do.

The poem is built on a quiet act of personification. The leaves, "last autumn's" leftovers, lie "pressed flat as ears / to the forest floor." The simile makes the whole woodland seem to be listening, like someone with an ear to the ground for footsteps or hoofbeats. It also fits the physical truth: leaves that have spent months under snow really do end up matted and pinned down. The adjective "barely" in "barely stir in the wind" adds to the stillness. Even the wind can hardly move them, as if they are holding their breath.

Then comes the poem's one human intrusion: "Surely they know what's coming." The word "surely" is revealing. It sounds confident, but it is a guess, a speaker projecting awareness onto leaves. The sentence also never says what is coming. Spring is the obvious answer, and the poem's scene fits a thaw, but it never says so. That gap is where the unease lives. "What's coming" could be warmth, or something heavier.

The final stanza moves from surface to underneath. "Stones lie askew" is blunt, a flat three-word statement of disorder. Judging by the imagery, the stones could be gravestones or simply rocks shifted by frost, and the poem leaves that open. The next sentence settles the mood. "Whatever is beneath them shows no sign / of resting in peace." The phrase "resting in peace" is borrowed from epitaphs, and here it is turned against itself. "Whatever" is also a chilling choice. It is not "whoever," so we cannot tell if it is a body, a creature, a root or a seed. The poem stays deliberately unspecific, and the stirring below the ground feels more unsettling for it.

The form supports this restraint. There are three tercets, a tidy, almost boxed-in shape, and there is no regular rhyme or meter. Yet there is one faint echo: "snow" in the first line returns as "know" in the sixth. The two words sit at the ends of lines, in different stanzas, and they link the cold that has just passed with the knowledge the leaves seem to have. The syntax also works against the stanza breaks. The first sentence runs across the gap between stanzas one and two, so the leaves' sentence seems to press downward, just as they do. Line lengths shift with the mood. The third stanza opens on a short, hard statement, then stretches into the long line "Whatever is beneath them shows no sign," and then shrinks again to the five-word "of resting in peace." The poem slows at the point where the dread arrives, then ends quickly with its twisted cliché.

The diction is plain and mostly everyday: "snow," "wind," "stones," "floor." The strangeness comes from how those words are arranged, not from ornament. That plainness is part of why the poem is significant. In very few words it takes an ordinary seasonal observation and makes it uncanny, and it questions the habit of treating spring as only a reward. The poem asks the reader to notice how a landscape can seem aware, and how an image as simple as flattened leaves can carry a feeling of dread. Its brevity, close to that of a haiku, leaves the ending open. The poem does not tell us whether what rises will be a blessing or a threat, and that uncertainty is what stays with the reader.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss