Terminology — Poem analysis

Dave BontaContemplative

Earth tones—a term no recent migrant from the tropics would understand,

how a dormant earth can come in moss-green, bark-gray and a thousand browns—

umber, ochre, sienna— and spring still a hollow gurgling somewhere below.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Some words only make sense if you have lived inside the thing they describe. "Terminology" begins from that idea. "Earth tones" is the kind of phrase we meet on paint charts and clothing labels, and we rarely stop to ask what it means. The poem stops. It imagines a "recent migrant from the tropics" who would find the term baffling. The poem never says whether this migrant is a person or a bird, and it doesn't need to. Either way, this is someone arriving from a place where the ground is never "dormant," and for whom a palette named after bare earth would seem a strange idea.

The poem's grammar carries its meaning. Everything in the first two stanzas is one slow, unfolding sentence. It hangs on the comma after "would understand," and the explanation, "how a dormant earth / can come in moss-green, bark-gray / and a thousand browns," spills over the stanza break. We are made to wait for the answer, which mimics the way a newcomer would gradually learn to see. The answer is also a surprise. Green and gray turn up inside a category we thought meant brown. The first two colors are named after things you could touch, moss and bark, so the winter landscape arrives with texture as well as hue.

Then comes the dash, and the "thousand browns" become specific: "umber, ochre, sienna." These are not arbitrary color words. They are names of pigments, traditionally made from earth, so "earth tones" turns literal. The ground is not just resembling these colors, it is where they come from. The sound shifts too. "Moss-green, bark-gray" is clipped, with stresses piling up against each other. The three pigment names open out, with a lilting beat on "UM-ber," "O-chre," "si-EN-na," as if the speaker were relishing them, saying them aloud like a litany.

The last stanza turns from the eye to the ear. "And spring still a hollow gurgling / somewhere below" has no verb, and the missing verb suits a season that has not yet started to act. "Still" works two ways, meaning "not yet" and also "motionless." "Hollow" suggests a space beneath the surface, and "gurgling" is onomatopoeia, the g sounds almost bubbling in the mouth. Judging by the imagery, we are meant to picture meltwater moving unseen through the ground. The poem ends on "below," so the last word sends us under the surface. After all that looking at the palette, we are told that the real event is happening out of sight.

That ending changes how we read the browns. They no longer look like the absence of color but like a waiting room, a surface hiding something under way. The tropics are never described in the poem, yet they haunt it by contrast. We supply the lushness ourselves, and against it the winter earth looks subtler and more rewarding.

The form is spare. There are three tercets, no rhyme and no regular meter, and the lines run from a few syllables to a handful, which keeps the voice quiet and conversational. In place of rhyme, sound does the binding. "Term" and "tones" echo each other in the first line, and "term" returns the poem to its title. "Terminology" is a dry, almost scientific word, and it sets up a gentle irony. Vocabulary is tidy, while the thing it names is crowded with a thousand shades and a hidden pulse. A word like "earth tones" is only a label, and the poem shows how much it leaves out.

What makes the poem worth reading is how much it fits into so few lines. It is a nature poem that avoids easy beauty. Its subject is the dormant season, which many people dismiss as dull, and it argues that seeing richly depends on having the right words and the patience to look closely. A person who has learned the winter palette sees what a stranger might call mud. The poem also leaves a small, hopeful sound underground, a promise that the quiet colors are not the end of the story.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss