The Hollow (5) — Poem analysis

Dave BontaContemplative

ark ark

so many ways of saying here in Raven

the aging spruces still stand where we planted them

their insurgent roots

rings of mushrooms between the lines of trees

one woodfern waving

shaggy manes

imagine the sweet release of autodigestion

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

The poem opens with a sound rather than a sentence: "ark ark." The wide gap between the two words works like a pause between calls across a valley. The next lines explain it. There are "so many ways of saying here / in Raven," so the croaks are a language, and the speaker is listening for what they mean. "Ark" also happens to be an ordinary English word, and a reader who knows the story of Noah, who sent out a raven from the ark, may catch an echo of shelter and survival. The poem never says so, but the sound carries that possibility. The title, "The Hollow," suggests a small enclosed valley, and the poem is about what it means to belong in a place like that.

Belonging here is complicated. "The aging spruces / still stand where we planted them" admits a human hand: these trees were put in the ground by "we," in what the later phrase "between the lines of trees" tells us are rows. Yet the spruces are not simply obedient. Their "insurgent roots" is the poem's most charged phrase. "Insurgent" belongs to rebellion and politics, and it turns the roots into a quiet uprising against the planter's straight lines. The poem does not say how this happens. It leaves the roots as a fragment on a line of their own, so the word can sit there and unsettle things.

The mushrooms carry that idea further. Their "rings" are circles growing in the gaps between the human rows. Lines are what people draw, and rings are what the forest does when no one is directing it. "Lines" also hints at lines of verse, so the poet may be nudging us to see the poem's own spare, ruled-off shape as one more thing planted in the hollow. That reading is an inference, but the poem's layout encourages it: each image gets its own space, and the white around it is as important as the words.

The rhythm is slow, with no rhyme, no punctuation and no full sentence until the last line. Phrases arrive one at a time, like things noticed on a walk. "One woodfern waving" is the gentlest of them. The "w" sounds nearly repeat, and the single fern is a small, living detail against the mass of spruces and fungi. Then "shaggy manes" arrives as a bare two-word line. The phrase sounds like a description of hair, and it is also the name of a mushroom. A reader who knows that the shaggy mane dissolves into black liquid soon after it matures will see what is coming. If you don't know it, the final stanza explains: "imagine the sweet release / of autodigestion."

That ending changes the poem's register. Until now the vocabulary has been simple and sensory: spruces, roots, rings, fern. "Autodigestion" is a clinical, almost laboratory word, and the poem sets it beside "sweet release," which sounds like relief or even desire. The collision is surprising and slightly funny, but it is also serious. The mushroom is being asked to be an example of how to end: not fighting, just coming undone from within and returning to the ground that feeds the roots, the ferns and the next rings of mushrooms. "Imagine" is an instruction, addressed to the reader or perhaps to the speaker, and it makes this a request to try on a different attitude toward death.

This links back to the opening. If there are many ways of saying "here" in Raven, the poem suggests that decay is one of them. Being in a place fully means accepting its cycle of planting, growth, rebellion and dissolution. The spruces are aging, the roots are pushing, and the mushrooms are already rotting. The title's "(5)" suggests this is one piece in a sequence, so the poem may be one of several attempts to learn the language of this place.

What makes the poem worth reading is its compression. In about a dozen short lines it puts human order against wild order, uses a bird's call as a language, and ends on a word that sounds more like a textbook than a poem and still manages to sound tender. It borrows the stillness and attentiveness of haiku without following its syllable count, and it asks readers to treat decomposition as something other than a loss.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Fairy Bells

Prosartes lanuginosa Their ringing isn’t obvious; you need the ear of an anchorite to find them.
CheerfulDave Bonta

Homunculus

Within my mind a mind I long to tame— a left boy, a little Hercules, the king of ham.