The Hollow (17) — Poem analysis

Dave BontaContemplative

where we fought many a rotten tomato battle common snakeroot

lawn and gardens gone back to meadow

the buildings’ straight lines

no more turning

even the electric meter is digital now

barn that once housed an elephant its great grey-green roof

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Read straight on from its title, the first line becomes a continuation: *The Hollow*, where we fought many a rotten tomato battle. Bonta starts mid-thought, as if the place were already being remembered before we have seen it. The "we" is never identified and the battle never explained. What survives is a game, messy and a little disgusting, the kind of fun that sounds like childhood, though the poem never says who was throwing. The number in the title suggests one poem in a series, but this one stands comfortably alone.

Next comes a plant name on a line by itself, "common snakeroot," with no verb to anchor it. Is it growing where the battles happened, or is it simply what the speaker notices now? Either way, the flat, almost field-guide label sets the tone. This will be an inventory, not a lament. The word itself, with its hiss and its buried root, brings in something wild and slow, and the next lines confirm it: "lawn and gardens gone / back to meadow." That phrase moves in two directions at once. "Gone" suggests loss, while "back" suggests return to an earlier state. In the poem, loss and return are the same event, and nobody has to destroy anything for it to happen.

The middle stanzas are the hardest to pin down. "the buildings' straight lines" has no verb, so we cannot tell whether the buildings are standing firm or starting to sag. Straight lines are a human habit, and here they sit against a landscape curving back into meadow. Then "no more turning" arrives, again without an object. It could mean the turning of garden soil, or the turning of seasons of work. One possible answer appears a stanza later, when "even the electric meter / is digital now." If we picture the spinning dial of an older meter, the earlier line looks like a quiet setup. The word "even" is dry and nearly comic. It implies that the one thing still being kept up to date in this fading place is the machinery that counts. It also hints, as an inference from the text, that the buildings are still wired and still billed, so the modern world has not let go of the hollow even as the lawn gives way.

Then the final image arrives: "barn that once / housed an elephant." The line break leans hard on "once," and the scale jumps. After tomatoes, a weed and a meter, the past turns out to have held something enormous. The poem offers no explanation, and it doesn't need one. Anyone who has stood in a place with a history they only half know will recognize the feeling. The last line, "its great grey-green roof," has no verb and no full stop, so it simply stops. The colours are worth noticing. Grey is the colour of an elephant, and green is the colour of the meadow. Judging by the imagery, the roof is weathering into both, the animal's memory and the land's reclaiming meeting in one surface. The sounds help too. "Great grey-green" is a slow, heavy run of hard g's and long vowels, and it makes the phrase feel as weighty as its subject.

Formally, the poem is free verse with no rhyme and no punctuation at all, not even capitals inside the text. Its lines are short, mostly between three and seven syllables, and the stanzas are uneven, with single lines like "no more turning" left alone in white space. That white space does the work of time. Each pause is a stretch of quiet in which the place carries on changing without anyone watching.

What makes the poem worth reading is how much feeling it gets from how little it says. It never uses a word like "grief" or "nostalgia." Memory works through objects instead: a fruit fight, a weed, a meter, a roof. The mood moves from playful to wry to quietly awed, and the elephant keeps it from turning into a simple complaint about time passing. The past here was not just gentler. It was bigger, stranger and more surprising than the present, and the poem leaves that thought hanging, like the last line, without a full stop.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Fairy Bells

Prosartes lanuginosa Their ringing isn’t obvious; you need the ear of an anchorite to find them.
CheerfulDave Bonta

Homunculus

Within my mind a mind I long to tame— a left boy, a little Hercules, the king of ham.