Skyline — Poem analysis

Dave BontaContemplative

the moving domes of umbrellas

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Two short lines, no verb, no punctuation, and a whole city rearranges itself. Dave Bonta's "Skyline" gives us only a noun phrase, "the moving domes / of umbrellas", and leaves us to supply the rest: a crowded street, a viewer looking down or along it, and the sudden sense that the people have vanished and something grander has taken their place.

The poem works through the order in which it hands over information. The title comes first, and "Skyline" promises buildings against the sky, the fixed outline a city shows off on postcards. Then comes "domes", which is still architecture and suggests cathedrals, mosques and council chambers, structures meant to outlast their builders. Only the final word pulls the rug away: umbrellas. We have built a monument in our heads and now watch it fold down into something cheap, collapsible and carried in one hand. Notice, too, that the grand image arrives before the ordinary object. Most comparisons start with the everyday thing and reach upward for something impressive. Here the impressive version comes first and the everyday one lands as a small, pleasing surprise.

The word "moving" does the most unsettling work. A skyline is supposed to stay put, which is the whole point of having one. By placing "moving" between "the" and "domes", Bonta lets motion invade the architecture before we understand why. The poem has no finite verb, yet it is far from static. That one participle suggests bobbing, tilting, bunching at crossings and sliding past each other, a roofline that reshuffles with every step. It is a skyline made of people, though the people are never mentioned. They are hidden beneath their canopies, so the poem shows roofs and no faces. That may be a quiet comment on city life, where everyone is anonymous and hurrying, each sealed inside a private shelter. There is some tenderness in the picture as well. A dome is a covering, and here each walker carries a portable one.

The poem never says it is raining, but the umbrellas imply it. Judging by the image, the weather is part of what goes unsaid, and the poem trusts us to hear it. A grey, wet day and a monumental skyline also make a fitting pair. The impermanence of the umbrella domes only shows how permanent the real ones are. This skyline will disappear the moment the rain stops, and every umbrella closes.

The sound of the lines supports the picture. Each line has four syllables, so the poem has a tidy, balanced shape despite its lack of rhyme. The line break after "domes" gives the grand image a moment to stand on its own before the small hinge-word "of" tips us toward the reveal. The letter *m* runs through the poem, in "moving", "domes" and "umbrellas", a soft hum that links the three key words. The vowels in "moving", "domes" and "um-" also make the lips round, so the mouth briefly forms the curve it is describing. That may be coincidence, but it fits the poem's habit of letting small things carry large effects. The long word "umbrellas" sits alone on the second line and swells in the middle, on "-brel-", then trails off in the soft "-las", like a canopy opening and settling.

The poem is significant because it demonstrates how much can be done with almost nothing. It reads in the spirit of very short imagistic poems, which rely on a single observed moment and leave the feeling to the reader. It also shows that a title can be part of a poem's meaning, since without "Skyline" the two lines would be a pleasant description and nothing more. And it offers a lesson in metaphor without the signposts. There is no "like" or "as", just one swapped word, and the reader does the rest.

Perhaps the best thing about it is how it changes the way you walk through a wet street afterwards. You look at the ordinary scene and see a skyline moving past, then glance up at your own umbrella and realise you are carrying part of it.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss