Oaks as Teachers — Poem analysis

Dave BontaInspired

give me shade tolerance so i can worship the sun at a cellular level

teach me the dance in abundance the sects of insects

how to work like an artist’s model with wind or fire

how to mine in place and turn the soil into an accomplice

how to communicate with an alien life form in speech acts of pure energy

how to grow wound wood walling off all the hollow broken places

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

A title like "Oaks as Teachers" sounds like a course description, and the poem delivers a syllabus: six requests, each for something a tree does without apparent effort. But the speaker is no detached student. Every stanza is a plea ("give me," "teach me," "how to"), and the lowercase, unpunctuated lines sound less like a lecture than a prayer murmured in a wood. The central idea is that the oak models a way of living humans find hard: thriving in imperfect conditions, staying put, working with surrounding forces rather than against them, and surviving damage without pretending it never happened.

The opening request is a small paradox. "Shade tolerance" is an ecological term for how well a plant copes with low light, yet the speaker wants it "so i can worship the sun." Devotion, the poem suggests, depends on enduring the dimness between moments of brightness. "At a cellular level" turns worship into chemistry, so that faith becomes something the body does rather than something the mind declares. Religious language keeps surfacing, and it gets a joke in the second stanza, where the oak's crowd of insect residents becomes "the sects of insects," as if every beetle belonged to a rival congregation. That phrase and the earlier "dance / in abundance" are the closest the poem comes to rhyme. Both are chimes about plenty, so the poem's few musical moments celebrate crowded, generous life. Elsewhere the lines are short, with two or three stresses each, and the missing punctuation lets the line breaks carry the meaning. "Teach me the dance / in abundance" can be read as a lavish dance or as learning to live amid abundance, and the poem leaves both open.

The middle stanzas rely on oxymoron and surprising verbs. An "artist's model" works by holding still while someone else interprets her, so "work" here means patient endurance. Wind or fire becomes the artist, shaping the pose. "Mine in place" is a similar knot, since mining usually means going somewhere and digging something out, while the oak mines from a single spot. The soil becomes an "accomplice," a word borrowed from heists and mild crime. It is funny, and it also implies partnership, as though the tree and the ground share a quiet secret. Judging by the imagery, the speaker admires cooperation that looks almost conspiratorial.

The fifth stanza is the most abstract. "Speech acts" is a term from linguistics for utterances that do something, like promising or naming, and the poem pairs it with "pure energy." The oak's language, the poem seems to say, is not words but exchange, perhaps of light, chemistry or heat. The phrase "alien life form" is deliberately ambiguous. The tree may be alien to us, or we may be alien to it. Either way, the speaker admits the gap between species is wide enough that communication has to be learned.

The final stanza is where the poem stops being purely admiring and becomes personal. "Wound wood" is the real term for the tissue a tree grows around an injury. The oak does not erase damage but walls it off, and the speaker's wish is to do the same with "all the hollow / broken places." The poem never says whose hollows these are, which lets the reader fill them in. The sounds reinforce the image: *wound wood*, *walling*, *hollow* all share breathy w and h sounds, like air moving through an empty trunk. The poem also ends without a full stop and without a promise of healing. The hollows remain, contained but alive, and that is a more modest and believable kind of hope than cure.

This shape is part of what makes the poem worth reading. It begins with sun-worship and abundance and ends with scars, so the lessons get harder as it goes. It also avoids the sentimental tree poem in which nature simply consoles us. Here the tree is a demanding teacher, and the poem's blend of scientific vocabulary ("cellular," "wound wood") with spiritual vocabulary ("worship," "sects") suggests that paying close attention to a living thing can itself be a form of reverence.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss