Deprivation addict — Poem analysis

Dave BontaAnxious

Look upon these hips fit for a board and eat. Unwilling flesh, breast of necessity— being ill for want of it I fear a clear life, pray it may not tempt me to eat not.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Dave Bonta's twelve-line poem opens like a showman's patter or a priest's summons: "Look upon / these hips fit / for a board / and eat." The speaker puts their own body on display, and the instruction that follows is strange. Look, and then eat. The word "board" does double duty. It can be a flat plank, which suggests hips as thin as wood, and it can be a dinner table, as in "room and board." The body becomes both the surface and the meal. "And eat" also recalls the communion words "take, eat," so a plain act of nourishment starts to sound like a ritual in which the body is offered up.

The title supplies the central idea: "Deprivation addict." Addiction normally means craving something taken in, but here the craving is for absence. The poem never names a condition, and I would hesitate to pin one on it, yet the hips, the "unwilling flesh" and the illness suggest the logic of self-starvation. Whatever the speaker's exact situation, the poem is about hunger that has turned into a kind of devotion.

The middle lines pack in a lot. "Unwilling flesh" twists the familiar saying that the spirit is willing but the flesh is weak. Here the flesh is the one resisting, as though the body were the last honest party in a quarrel with the mind. "Breast of necessity" is richly ambiguous. A breast can be a chest, a source of milk, or a cut of meat, and the poem reduces all of these to need. The dash after "necessity" then opens into the diagnosis: "being ill for / want of it." "Want" means both lack and desire, and the poem lets the two meanings blur. The line break helps, because "being ill for" hangs for a moment before "want of it" completes it. Even "it" floats free. It might be food, or nourishment in general, or the deprivation itself. The speaker may be sick from going without, or from wanting to go without, and the syntax declines to say which.

The ending turns on a reversal. "I fear a clear life" works partly through the chime of "fear" and "clear." "Clear" suggests clean, empty and unclouded, a cleared plate and a cleared head, the lightness hunger can seem to promise. The speaker is afraid of that clarity, and the next move is a prayer: "pray it may / not tempt me / to eat not." Temptation has been turned inside out. In the old moral vocabulary, temptation pulls toward indulgence, but here it pulls toward refusal. The archaic "eat not" gives abstinence the sound of a commandment, as in "thou shalt not," so the speaker's private compulsion is dressed in scripture's grammar. It also echoes the poem's own fourth line. The poem begins with "and eat" and closes on "eat not," so the whole piece is framed by a command and its negation.

The form enacts the same restraint. The lines are tiny, mostly three syllables, with the longest, "breast of necessity," only six. There is no regular rhyme, but sound ties the poem together quietly. "Fit" in line 2 meets "it" in line 8, and the long *e* of "eat," "necessity" and "me" returns like a hunger pang. Enjambment also plays tricks. "These hips fit" first reads as healthy, and only "for a board" pulls the meaning toward plank and table. The poem is itself lean, with hardly a spare word or decorative adjective, so it practices the deprivation it describes.

What makes the poem worth reading is that it neither diagnoses nor cures. It gives the condition an inner logic, borrowing the language of temptation and prayer to show how appetite and virtue can swap places. The speaker is both exhibit and confessor, displaying the body in the first line and begging for help in the last. The poem stops at the prayer, not at a recovery, so it leaves the reader inside the uncertainty. A reader can feel how reasonable the speaker's logic seems from within, and how frightening that is.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss