Lenore — Poem analysis

I wrote against night and forgetting for a lady still as thought

we had a plain dinner among the graves

the hill slept in the manner of cut stone

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

A poet announces that he has written "against night and forgetting," then spends the remaining five lines doing something far quieter than fighting: eating dinner in a graveyard. The gap between that grand opening vow and the modest scene that follows is where Dave Bonta's "Lenore" does its work. Its central idea is that memory and mourning may be less a battle than a patient, ordinary act of keeping company with the dead.

The title matters. For many readers, the name Lenore recalls Poe's lost beloved in "The Raven," so we arrive expecting elegy. Whether or not Bonta intended the echo, the poem never says outright that anyone has died. Judging by the imagery, though, the "graves," the stillness and the stone all point that way. What it refuses is Gothic excess. There is no tolling bell or midnight chamber, only a "plain dinner."

The first couplet sets the stakes. "Wrote against" can mean writing in opposition to something, but it can also suggest leaning one's work up against a wall to hold something back. The poem is itself the act it describes. "Night" and "forgetting" are abstractions, and they sit side by side as if they were the same enemy. Then comes the strangest phrase in the poem: "a lady still as thought." The word "lady" is courtly and old-fashioned, the way a poet might address a muse or a figure on a tomb. The simile puzzles us, because thought is not normally described as still. But "still" can mean motionless, silent or dead, and it can also mean "even now," so she is both quiet and persistent. Thought is also bodiless, something that exists only inside a mind, which is exactly where a remembered person lives.

The second couplet drops from abstraction to table-level reality. "We had a plain dinner / among the graves" is the only moment of shared action in the poem, and the "we" quietly includes the lady. "Plain" is the key word. It rejects ceremony and sentiment, and it suggests that the living and the dead can share bread without any theatrical fuss. The line break gives "among the graves" a line to itself, so the phrase arrives flatly, like a fact. The meal is a small communion, ordinary life carrying on right alongside death.

The final image is the most unsettling. "The hill slept" uses the old euphemism for death, but the simile that follows, "in the manner of cut stone," undoes any comfort. This is not restful sleep. The word "cut" brings in human labour, the chisel and the headstone, so the natural hill seems to imitate the monuments scattered over it. "Manner" is a stiff, formal word that also suggests manners and courtesy, which suits both the lady and the dinner. It even chimes faintly with "dinner" two lines earlier, since both words end on the same unstressed "-ner."

The poem's sound is quiet but deliberate. It has no rhyme scheme, but "still" in line two and "hill" in line five make a true rhyme across stanzas, tying the lady to the landscape so that they share one condition. The s-and-t sounds then harden the poem as it goes: "still," "slept," "stone." Each couplet is a small unit of three, with no capital letters or punctuation. Without a full stop, the last image is never formally closed, and the hill's sleep simply goes on. The movement from "night," "forgetting" and "thought" to "dinner," "graves," "hill" and "stone" also runs from the abstract to the concrete, and the most concrete image turns out to be the eeriest.

What makes the poem worth reading is its restraint and its honesty about what poems can do. It does not claim to defeat night or to bring Lenore back. It offers a record of one plain evening and the stone-still landscape around it. Yet by being written down, and by being read now, the poem has already done a little of what its first line promised.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Fairy Bells

Prosartes lanuginosa Their ringing isn’t obvious; you need the ear of an anchorite to find them.
CheerfulDave Bonta

Homunculus

Within my mind a mind I long to tame— a left boy, a little Hercules, the king of ham.