Las Californias, 1769 — Poem analysis

the land has been our home they have walls

in every mind a box they call God

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Seventeen words, and a whole collision of worlds. The title does much of the framing: "Las Californias" is a Spanish name, in the plural, paired with a year in the eighteenth century. Judging by that, the poem sits in the era of colonial encounter. Yet the lines themselves never use the name. They say only "the land." The newcomers' label stays in the title, while the speaker, a collective voice that says "our," refuses to repeat it. The central idea is a contrast between two ways of occupying the earth. One belongs to a place. The other encloses it, and the poem suggests the deepest enclosure happens in the mind.

The first stanza sets the contrast up through its verbs. "The land has been our home" is a statement of being, not owning. Nobody here claims a deed or a boundary, only a long, settled belonging. The present perfect "has been" is quietly loaded, since it stretches from the past up to now and leaves open whether it can continue. Then comes the blunt reply: "they have walls." The verb changes from "been" to "have," from dwelling to possessing. The poem barely needs to say what the walls do. Home, in this vocabulary, is something you inhabit, and a wall is something you hold against others.

The second stanza turns the same idea inward. "In every mind a box" shrinks the architecture from a wall that encloses a settlement to a box that encloses a thought. The word "every" is the most interesting choice here. It could mean every mind among the newcomers, but it could also hint that the box is being installed in everyone, including the speaker's own people. I read that ambiguity as part of the poem's unease. Then the last line: "they call God." The verb "call" matters. The speaker does not say the box is God, only that this is what *they* call it, so the name is theirs and the speaker declines to endorse it. A box is also something you can close, label and carry, so the image quietly suggests a god small enough to be contained. That is an interpretation, but the poem's pairing of "box" and "call" invites it. Notice, too, that "God" is the only capitalised word in the poem. Everything else is lowercase, so the newcomers' convention of reverence stands out like a rigid object in a soft landscape.

The form reinforces the argument. The syllable count runs six, three, six, three, and the two stanzas are built identically: a long line, then a short one. The long lines are almost perfect iambic trimeter, "the LAND has BEEN our HOME" and "in EV'ry MIND a BOX," and they move with an easy, walking rhythm. The short lines then land with heavier stress: "they HAVE WALLS," "they CALL GOD." Each stanza opens out and then shuts, which is the poem's whole point in miniature. There is no end rhyme, but "walls" and "call" share a vowel and sit in matching positions, and the repeated "they have" and "they call" make the two short lines a pair. Each line also ends on a hard, closed sound: "walls," "box," "God." The poem has no punctuation at all, no full stops and no capitals to open the lines. It sounds like a spoken voice rather than an official record, and the lack of a final full stop leaves the thought hanging.

What makes the poem worth reading is its restraint. It names no violence, no ships and no soldiers. It does not even use an adjective to tell us whom to side with. It trusts two plain nouns, "walls" and "box," to carry the argument, and it implies that conquest is first a habit of thought and only later a building project. The contrast between "home" and "walls" is so simple that it is almost uncomfortable, because it leaves readers to notice which of those words they live by. The poem is tiny, but it manages to be both a lament and an accusation without raising its voice.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss