Parts unknown — Poem analysis

Dave BontaContemplative

I am an ordinary person ingenuity is better than thinking

the puppet-plays I act in give me new parts a late foot a head full of order

that absence of joy I perceive as art though I contrive to have no room for it

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Six lines, three couplets, no punctuation but a single hyphen, and no capital letter except the pronoun "I": Dave Bonta's "Parts unknown" looks plain on the page, yet it packs a whole anxious argument about selfhood into a few dozen words. Its speaker seems to feel like a stand-in for a person, acting out roles written elsewhere. The central idea, as I read it, is that self-awareness can harden into a performance of its own. The speaker perceives an "absence of joy" as "art" and then, by design, keeps it that way.

The opening couplet sets the tone. "I am an ordinary person" is flat, almost like a line on a form, the kind of thing people say to disarm you. With no full stop to separate it from "ingenuity is better than thinking", the two lines can be read as cause and effect or as two unrelated claims, and the reader has to choose. The maxim is odd either way. It prefers cleverness at making things work over reflection, yet the speaker is plainly thinking hard, so the line seems to undercut itself. It could be a boast, an excuse, or a rule the speaker half-believes.

The second couplet brings in the central image. "The puppet-plays I act in give me new parts" works on two levels, because "parts" means both theatrical roles and pieces of a body. The next line makes the body literal: "a late foot a head full of order." The result is a puppet put together from mismatched pieces, a foot that arrives after the cue and a tidy, over-organised head. Mind and body are out of step, and the control sits somewhere else. "Late" may also carry a faint echo of "the late", meaning dead, though that is only a possibility. The title adds to this, since "parts unknown" recalls the phrase for a destination nobody can name. Here it suggests a self whose components, and whose future roles, can't be identified.

The final couplet turns on two verbs. "Perceive" is passive, a matter of receiving an impression, while "contrive" is active and faintly scheming. The speaker both sees the emptiness and builds it. "That absence of joy" points back to something already familiar, as if it were an old acquaintance. The last phrase, "no room for it", is deliberately slippery. The "it" could be joy, art, or the absence itself. It also answers the earlier "head full of order": a head that is full has no space left. The ingenuity praised in line two returns as "contrive", now revealed as the very skill that keeps joy out.

The poem has no end-rhyme, since "person/thinking", "parts/order" and "art/it" share nothing. But sound still links the lines. The word "art" sits inside "parts", so the title quietly contains the thing the speaker claims to see. The p-sounds in "person", "puppet-plays" and "parts" give the middle of the poem a clipped, wooden click, which suits a puppet. "Perceive" and "contrive" look alike on the page, like an eye-rhyme, though they sound different. The rhythm is loose and conversational, with lines running to roughly eight or nine syllables and no fixed metre. Without punctuation, each reader decides where to pause, so the reader ends up working the strings.

What makes the poem significant, I think, is its refusal to settle the question it raises. Is the speaker a victim of other people's scripts, or the author of their own emptiness? The poem's wit lies in making both readings possible, and in showing how irony can become a defence: if you call your numbness "art", you never have to ask whether you want it. For a poem this short, that is a lot of unease, and the plain voice of its opening line, "I am an ordinary person", makes the unease feel closer to home.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Fairy Bells

Prosartes lanuginosa Their ringing isn’t obvious; you need the ear of an anchorite to find them.
CheerfulDave Bonta

Homunculus

Within my mind a mind I long to tame— a left boy, a little Hercules, the king of ham.