Mother crow — Poem analysis

without prejudice to mine who would the great leaders punish fear is a game

poor people examined as suspected persons that they pitch upon to torture

our mother crow in a strange hour commanded to ask who we were

her face full of black rain like poison for a rook

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Twelve lowercase lines, no punctuation, and a lot of fear: Dave Bonta's "Mother crow" moves from the cold language of governments to the image of a bird's ruined face, and it never explains the join. It is about how power makes ordinary people into suspects, and how that damage lands on something as basic as a mother's ability to say who her children are. Its central idea is stated in the middle of the first stanza, flat as a proverb: "fear is a game."

The opening is deliberately hard to pin down. "Without prejudice to mine" borrows the phrase "without prejudice" from legal and diplomatic language, the kind of wording used to protect one party while making concessions. Here it is left dangling, and "mine" could mean "my people," "my own," or simply what belongs to me. Then comes "who would the great leaders punish," a question with no question mark. Because the punctuation is missing, the line reads as a question and a statement at once, a wondering and a shrug. "Great leaders" is almost certainly ironic, since the next line reduces their world to a "game," something played with pieces that can be sacrificed.

The second stanza makes that game concrete. "Poor people examined / as suspected persons" has the flavor of an official report, and the word "examined" is chilling because it could mean questioned, searched or inspected like an object. The last line of the stanza, "that they pitch upon to torture," is the longest and slowest in the poem, and its slightly old-fashioned phrase "pitch upon" matters. To pitch upon something is to light on it almost at random. The victims are not chosen for what they have done, only because they are poor and available. The sound of the poem supports this. Hard p's run through it like a drumbeat: "prejudice," "punish," "poor people," "persons," "pitch," and finally "poison." The words that open the poem and the one that closes it are linked, as if the whole piece were being pressed out through the same clenched lips.

Then the poem changes register. "Our mother crow / in a strange hour / commanded to ask who we were" drops the committee-room vocabulary for something closer to myth or fable. The word "our" matters, because the speaker is now one of the crow's brood, and the poor people from stanza two have become her children. The passive "commanded" is the strangest choice. Someone gives her orders, but we are not told who, and it is unclear whether she is being forced to interrogate her own family or to ask the questions that power wants asked. Either way, the most natural bond, a mother knowing her young, has been turned into a procedure. The "strange hour" has the feel of a night knock on the door.

The final stanza gives the poem its most vivid image: "her face full / of black rain / like poison for a rook." The line break after "full" makes the face brim over before we learn what it is full of. "Black rain" suggests soot, ash or pollution, though the poem does not say what it is, and that restraint keeps it unsettling. The simile is odd because a rook is itself a black bird of the crow family, so the poison seems made of her own kind of darkness, turned against her. The word "rook" may also carry two other meanings: it is a chess piece, which echoes the "game," and "to rook" someone means to swindle them. The poem does not insist on either reading, but both fit its world of rigged play.

The poem's rhythm is short and plain, with no rhyme and no regular meter. The lines run from three or four syllables to the long, dragging "that they pitch upon to torture," so the structure mimics the way an official sentence can suddenly lengthen and swallow a person. Four tercets give it the look of order, which makes the content more disturbing.

What makes the poem worth reading is its compression and its refusal to lecture. It never names a country, a regime or a date, so it can be read as a comment on any system that uses fear and arbitrary suspicion. By ending on an image of a bird's face rather than an argument, it leaves readers with the human cost instead of the political theory, and with the uneasy feeling that the game has already been played.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss