Modern Times — Poem analysis

times pass only for show in this wonder-starved country among levers and puppets

their music is one gear peaking cruel and high

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Six lines, no punctuation, no capital letters, and a whole way of life is put on trial. Dave Bonta's "Modern Times" is tiny, but it works like a trap. It opens with a calm observation, "times pass / only for show," and ends by turning the machinery of modern life into something that sings, and sings badly.

The first line carries a pun. "Times" is plural, echoing the title, so "times pass" can mean time going by or the eras themselves, the "modern times," drifting past like painted scenery. Either way, the passing is "only for show." Clocks keep turning and calendars keep flipping, but the poem suggests nothing underneath is moving. Progress here is a stage effect.

Then comes the poem's central diagnosis: a "wonder-starved country." The hyphen fuses two ideas, and "starved" is a strong word. It makes wonder a form of nourishment, so going without it is a hunger, not just a dull mood. "Country" is wonderfully vague. It could be a nation or a state of mind, and the poem never says which, so the accusation spreads in all directions.

The next line names who lives there: "levers and puppets." Both are things that do not move themselves. A lever waits for a hand, and a puppet hangs from strings. The poem never reveals who is doing the pulling, and the absence is unsettling. There is no "I," no "we," not a single named person. The inhabitants have been replaced by their equipment, or have become it. The title shares its name with Chaplin's film, and the gears and levers may recall its world of workers swallowed by machines. That link is my inference, since the poem never mentions the film, but it fits the mood.

The second stanza shrinks to a couplet, and the poem finds its one pronoun: "their music." It is a small, eerie moment, because "their" belongs to the levers and puppets, which gives lifeless things a voice. The music is "one gear peaking," and the word "one" matters. This is no orchestra, only a single repeating part. "Peaking" promises a climax, but what a gear produces at its peak is a whine of metal at speed. The final adjectives, "cruel and high," are the poem's sharpest turn. "High" describes shrill pitch, but "cruel" is a human quality. Either the machine has inherited the cruelty of whoever built it, or the poem is saying that cruelty is built into the system.

The form does a lot of quiet work. There is no rhyme and no regular meter, only free verse. But the lines have a shape. Counting syllables, they run roughly 2, 4, 7, 6, then 8, and then a sudden 3. The lines swell, as if a mechanism were winding up, and then the last line cuts short. Sound ties things together too. The hard p's of "pass," "puppets" and "peaking" click like parts meeting, and they link time, people and music in one mechanical chain. The vowels in "only," "show" and "wonder" are rounder and softer, which makes the harshness of the ending stand out. And "high" finishes on an open vowel with no consonant to close it. The poem doesn't resolve. It leaves a thin, shrill note hanging in the air.

What makes the poem significant is how much it does without explaining. It never says what has gone wrong, who is responsible, or what should replace the gears. It trusts three images (a show, a puppet theatre, a screeching machine) to carry the argument. Its targets, empty spectacle, automated routine and the loss of awe, are not tied to any one decade, so it can be read as a warning at almost any moment. The poem also works through an irony. A text that declares a country "wonder-starved" must itself be a small act of wonder, a few words that make the reader stop and listen to the sound of the machine.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Fairy Bells

Prosartes lanuginosa Their ringing isn’t obvious; you need the ear of an anchorite to find them.
CheerfulDave Bonta

Homunculus

Within my mind a mind I long to tame— a left boy, a little Hercules, the king of ham.