Cosmogony — Poem analysis

Dave BontaCheerful

the first office was a sun a great dirty star overtaking the coffee-house of our mother night

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Four lines are enough for Dave Bonta to rewrite the beginning of the universe as a bit of office politics. His title, "Cosmogony," promises something solemn. A cosmogony is an account of how the cosmos came to be, the sort of story that usually involves gods, chaos and a good deal of thunder. What we get is a sun that behaves like new management, marching into a room where people were happily talking and changing the mood for good.

The poem turns on the word "office." It can mean the fluorescent-lit workplace we picture first, but it also carries older senses of duty and appointed task. We still speak of holding an office, or of a religious office, a set of prayers said at fixed hours. A sun that is "the first office" is therefore both the original workplace and the original job, the first thing in creation with a function, something that must turn up every day and do its shift. The line states this flatly, "the first office was a sun," like an entry in a history textbook. The deadpan is where the joke lives.

The second line undercuts the grandeur at once. We expect a golden, life-giving sun, but Bonta gives us "a great dirty star." "Great" sounds like a title of honour, and "dirty" drags it through the mud. Three heavy stresses fall on "great," "dirt-" and "star," so the line lands slowly, like something being hauled into place. This sun is a furnace rather than a blessing, grimy with the effort of burning. The image suggests that work, even at the cosmic level, is not clean.

Then comes the intrusion: "overtaking the coffee-house / of our mother night." "Overtaking" does double duty. It describes what dawn physically does, creeping across and passing over the dark. It also has the sound of a takeover, a bigger operation swallowing a smaller one. What is swallowed is a coffee-house, an image of unhurried talk, small lamps and conversation that runs late because nobody has anywhere to be. There is a quiet irony in the choice, too. Coffee is what we drink to get through the working day, so even the night's gathering place is stocked with fuel for the sun's regime.

"Mother night" gives the dark a family role, and the possessive "our" pulls the reader inside it. We are the night's children, and daylight arrives as an outsider. Many creation stories begin with darkness before light, and Bonta uses that older order to make the sunrise feel like an interruption rather than a gift.

The poem's form supports this. There are no capital letters, no punctuation and no rhyme. It is a single sentence that never stops to breathe, much as light spreads without announcing itself. The lines run roughly seven, five, eight and five syllables. The third is the longest, and "overtaking the coffee-house" rolls forward on soft consonants and a dactyl-like lilt. Then the poem drops into the short, slow final line, "of our mother night." Its long vowels and its m and n sounds feel like a lullaby fading, the last murmur of the dark. A faint sound-echo links "house" at the end of one line with "our" at the start of the next, and "sun" and "mother" share a vowel. Judging by the sound alone, the invader and the invaded are oddly related.

What makes the poem worth reading is how much it fits into so little space. It treats the working day, which feels so human and so tedious, as something older than humanity, built into the design of the cosmos. It also reverses the usual story, in which light is good and darkness is the void. Here darkness is warm, social and maternal, and light is the one that clocks us in. Whether you laugh or feel a pang of sympathy for the night depends on how you feel about Monday mornings, and the poem leaves you to decide.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss