Mining region — Poem analysis

Dave BontaContemplative

in the heart of the country we expect no ambassador

coming here is coming home to ore and the ordinary feast

I am put in mind of a marsh with all the all they name nothing in it

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Nobody important is coming. That is the quiet announcement of Dave Bonta's opening couplet: "in the heart of the country / we expect no ambassador." "Heart of the country" works two ways. It can mean the inland interior, far from the borders and ports where envoys arrive, or a place that is central to the nation's sense of itself. An ambassador is someone sent from elsewhere to speak for a power, so expecting none suggests a region outside official attention. The tone is calm rather than aggrieved. The "we" does not complain of neglect; it reports a condition and moves on.

The second couplet turns arrival into return: "coming here is coming home to ore." The repeated "coming" does the work, because by the second time "here" has already become "home." What the speaker comes home to is not a house or a family but raw, unrefined mineral. Sound ties the line together. "Home," "ore" and "ordinary" share a rounded *o*, and the *-or* of "ambassador" comes back in "ore," as if the refused envoy's last syllable were quietly absorbed by the ground. Then comes the oxymoron "ordinary feast." A feast is meant to be an exception and "ordinary" says it is not. The phrase suggests plenty that nobody needs to dress up, and it is the warmest moment in the poem. Whether the feast is the ore itself, the living it provides, or the plain pleasure of belonging, the poem does not say.

Then something shifts. The communal "we" gives way to a single "I," and argument gives way to association: "I am put in mind of a marsh." The leap is odd, since a mining region is hard, dry and deep, while a marsh is soft, wet and shallow. Perhaps what links them is that both resist tidy classification. A marsh is neither quite land nor quite water, just as the ore-bearing ground is neither quite landscape nor quite resource. The last line is the most puzzling: "with all / the all they name nothing in it." The line break leaves "all" dangling at the end of a line, as if the speaker were reaching for totality, and the next line repeats the word and drops it into "nothing." With no punctuation, the sentence can be read at least two ways. It may mean that a marsh holds everything yet "they" give it no names. Or it may mean that the "all" they name has nothing in it. Who "they" are is never stated. Judging by the opening couplet, they could be the outsiders and officials who are not coming, but the poem leaves the reader to decide.

The form supports this. These are three unrhymed couplets in free verse, with no capital letters and no punctuation. The lines run to roughly seven to ten syllables with no fixed meter, and most of the words are plain and short. The few long words, "ambassador" and "ordinary," are the ones the poem pushes against, one refused and one made into a feast. The enjambment grows bolder as the poem goes on. The first two couplets break at natural pauses, but the last one snaps mid-phrase at "with all," so the poem loosens just as its meaning becomes harder to hold. The bare, unpolished surface resembles ore, and the reader has to do the refining by deciding where each thought stops.

What makes the poem interesting is that it practises what it describes. Its title names a type of place, "Mining region," rather than a particular one, and the poem never says what is mined, where, or who "we" are. It keeps its own territory unlabelled, so the reader is in the position of the unwelcome visitor who expects to be briefed and is handed an image of a marsh instead. In six lines it sets two ideas against each other: a place defined from outside by its resource and its absence of envoys, and a place that its own people know as home and ordinary abundance. By ending on "nothing" after "all," it suggests that naming can empty a place as easily as describe it, and that something may be fuller left unnamed.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss