Conflicts of interest — Poem analysis

Dave BontaAnxious

a field is in love with the sea as a ship is with land

where will we make war guided by lies

where finish the hanging or withdraw

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

The title of Dave Bonta's "Conflicts of interest" comes from the language of law, politics and finance, where it names a clash between private gain and public duty. The poem takes that phrase apart and lets its other meaning in. "Interest" is also attraction, the pull of one thing toward another, and the poem asks what happens when everything's longing points somewhere it cannot go, and when the same pull leads to violence.

The first couplet is a simile, and a lopsided one: "a field is in love with the sea / as a ship is with land." The two halves mirror each other. A field is land that longs for water, and a ship is a creature of water that longs for land. Each loves exactly what it is not, and each can only reach its beloved by ceasing to be itself. A ship that lands stops sailing, and a field that meets the sea is eaten by it. The sentence sounds like a gentle, almost pastoral observation, but it describes a love built on separation.

Then the word "field" starts to change. In the second couplet we get "where will we make war," and the field turns into a battlefield, the ship into a warship. The lovers' two territories, shore and sea, become possible theatres of conflict. The poem never says so, but the ground of desire and the ground of war look identical. The title's pun works the same way: the things we are drawn to are also the things we fight over.

The question is chilling for what it leaves out. It asks "where," not "whether." War is already assumed, and only its location is undecided. The "we" is also worth noticing, since it pulls the reader in as a participant. And "guided by lies" is deliberately loose. It could modify "we," or "war," or the whole act of choosing a battlefield. Because the first stanza has set up a ship, "guided" also carries a navigator's sense, as though the lies were a false compass. The poem does not say whose lies, so they could be anyone's, including our own.

The last couplet is the most compressed and the hardest to settle: "where finish the hanging / or withdraw." The grammar has worn away, with no "will we," no subject and no question mark. Meaning clings to the repeated "where," and the sentence seems to run out of breath as it goes. "Hanging" is the strangest word in the poem. "Finish the hanging" suggests an execution that has begun and not been completed, which makes the speaker sound like someone left to carry out a cruelty or abandon it. But a "hanging" can also be something suspended or unresolved, a matter left hanging. The poem does not choose. "Withdraw" works the same way. It is military retreat, but it can also mean pulling back from a promise or a feeling, which circles back to the opening love.

The form follows this narrowing. There are three unrhymed couplets, with no capitals and no punctuation at all. The lines tend to shorten as the poem goes on, from the fuller "a field is in love with the sea" to the clipped "or withdraw," as if the poem were itself retreating. The sound has its own pattern. The w's of "where," "will," "we," "war" and finally "withdraw" run through the second half like a repeated breath, binding the planning of war to its abandonment. Even the word "withdraw" contains "draw," which can mean pulling back or pulling a weapon.

The poem is significant because it does so much with so little. It names no particular war, no leader and no cause, which keeps it from being tied to a single event. A reader can supply their own. What remains is a structure: longing, then violence, then the choice between finishing and giving up. By beginning with love and ending with a gallows, the poem suggests that cruelty may begin in the same impulse as tenderness, a reaching toward something that is always on the far side of a boundary.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss