Public Relations — Poem analysis

Dave BontaCheerful

A letter from the general: my duty is to kill; my power, to write; my mission, to proclaim with great praise. Under the story of the king is the king. He calls me a very knowing man.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

A letter from a general ought to be a plain thing: orders, news, a list of losses. Dave Bonta's five lines give us something stranger, a self-portrait in which killing, writing and praising turn out to be one job. The title, "Public Relations," is a modern corporate phrase set against a world of generals and kings, and the clash is the first clue to the poem's idea. Whenever power uses force, someone is needed to turn that force into a story, and the poem lets that someone describe himself without noticing how much he gives away.

The middle lines work like a job description: "my duty is to kill; my power, to write; / my mission, to proclaim with great praise." The grammar is parallel, and in the second and third clauses the verb "is" quietly drops out, leaving a clipped, formulaic voice, like a motto stitched on a banner. The nouns climb in dignity, from duty to power to mission, while the verbs slide from act (kill) to record (write) to celebration (proclaim). The semicolons treat the three as equal items on a list, as if there were no moral distance between the first and the last. It is also unclear who is speaking. The letter comes "from the general," yet the speaker seems to be both soldier and scribe. The poem never says whether the general writes his own publicity or a hired voice speaks for him, and that blur is the point. It suggests one hand does both the deed and the telling.

There is no rhyme and no regular metre, but the sound is carefully managed. "Kill" and "write" are short, hard monosyllables, blunt as a door closing. Then the third line swells: "proclaim with great praise" is full of long vowels and a thick "pr" sound, and "great praise" is almost redundant, since praise already means approval. The phrase pads itself, and that padding is what flattery sounds like. The lines also grow with the praise. The second is tight and balanced, the third stretches out.

The fourth line is the one to linger on: "Under the story of the king is the king." Its syntax is inverted, so that we wait through "Under the story of the king" for the verb to arrive, and what it delivers is the same words again. The effect is a tautology that feels like a trapdoor. One reading is deflationary: strip away the story and you find only a man, nothing grander. A darker reading is that the story and the king cannot be separated, because the king is made of the telling. The repeated "the king" at both ends of the line wraps the sentence around its subject, much as the story wraps around him. It is also the only line that steps away from "my" and "me." The speaker stops reciting his duties and, for a moment, sounds like someone who has seen how the trick works.

The last line takes that glimpse and turns it into a reward: "He calls me a very knowing man." The "he" is presumably the king, judging by the line before, though the poem leaves the pronoun loose. "Knowing" cuts two ways. It can mean wise and well informed, but it can also mean complicit, as in a knowing look or a wink. The speaker repeats the compliment with pride, yet the flat, plain sentence and the small word "very" leave a chill. He is a man who knows what lies under the story and writes the story anyway. The praise also runs in a circle. He proclaims the king with great praise, and the king praises him back. That closed loop is public relations in miniature.

The poem matters because of how much it does in so little space. It never lectures about propaganda or names a war. It lets one self-satisfied voice incriminate itself, and it trusts the reader to hear what the speaker cannot. Because the setting is only a general and a king, the poem feels timeless, while the title pulls it straight into the present. Anyone who has read a press release, a slogan or a speech that makes harm sound like honour can recognise that voice. The poem's final unease is that the speaker is good at his job, and that being good at it is what he is proudest of.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Painted Trillium

Trillium undulatum Painted lady, late riser, you rush out of the ground, get pollinated on the fly
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Initiation

Let him continue in the ground, he who is now dead, where all things hurry—
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss