Retreat — Poem analysis

Dave BontaRomantic

My private bone, my chance heart, my Walden in a wardrobe, my rose— all night we lay in one green bed.

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Barely twenty words long, Dave Bonta's "Retreat" shrinks a whole tradition of solitude into a piece of bedroom furniture. The speaker lists what he holds dear, then reports one plain fact: "all night we lay / in one green bed." The poem never says who "we" are. Judging by the endearments, the other presence is most likely a lover, though it could also be read as the speaker lying down with the scattered parts of himself. Either way, the central idea is that the deepest retreat from the world is not a place but a closeness. The "retreat" of the title is shared, and it is made of intimacy rather than distance.

The opening line piles up unlikely names. "My private bone, my chance heart" sounds like a pet name, but not a sentimental one. Bone is what lies beneath skin, hidden and structural, so "private bone" suggests something essential and unshowable. "Chance heart" is odder. It could mean a heart found by luck, a love that happened rather than being planned, or one that carries a risk. The poem leaves the choice open, and that openness suits an affection too specific for ready-made words.

Then comes the line that gives the poem its force: "my Walden in a wardrobe." Walden is Thoreau's account of living simply beside a pond in the woods, so the name stands for withdrawal into nature. A wardrobe is a dark, closed, domestic box. Put together, they squeeze a whole wilderness into a cupboard, and the effect is both comic and tender. A wardrobe may also bring to mind the one in a famous children's story that opens onto another world, though that is an inference, not something the poem states. The image works either way, because the beloved becomes a hidden doorway into somewhere green and quiet. The list ends on "my rose," the only conventional love-word in it. After the strange coinages, the familiar symbol arrives almost like an exhale, and the dash that follows it is the poem's hinge.

The construction does a lot of quiet work. The first two lines are long and have no verb, so the sentence keeps reaching and the possessive "my" returns four times, like someone counting treasures. Only in the third line does the grammar land: "all night we lay." Here the language goes bare. Both closing lines are four syllables of plain monosyllables, and the rhythm slows to a rest, as if the poem were lying down too. The movement from a crowded "my, my, my" to a single "we" mirrors the poem's idea, since separate possessions become one shared state.

There is no end rhyme, but the sound is carefully knit. "Bone" and "rose" share a long o, which links the body to the flower. "Walden" and "wardrobe" chime through their w and d sounds, so the impossible pairing sounds inevitable. The b of "bone" comes back in "bed," bookending the poem with the body and its resting place. The ear may even catch a small joke between "rose" and "lay," which are the past tenses of "rise" and "lie," though that may be coincidence.

The last image, "one green bed," carries the poem's biggest surprise. Green belongs to Walden's woods, not to a bedroom, so the wardrobe's wilderness has spread to cover the bed. It suggests moss or grass, and perhaps something young and growing. Indoors and outdoors become the same place, and the lovers lie inside the retreat that the earlier lines only named. The title also gains a second meaning. A retreat can be a withdrawal, like a soldier's, or a refuge, like a quiet weekend away. The poem holds both, since the speaker steps back from the world and finds shelter at the same moment.

What makes the poem worth reading is its economy. It borrows a famous symbol of solitude and quietly changes it, making solitude something two people can inhabit. It does this without explaining itself, trusting a handful of images and a dash to carry the feeling. For a student, it is a useful reminder that a poem's weight depends on how much each word is made to hold, not on how many words there are.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss