Self-discovery — Poem analysis

All this vexing afternoon with a child crying at school— I am he.

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Most poems about self-discovery take their time. This one takes four short lines, and the discovery arrives so suddenly that it feels almost like a slip of the tongue. The speaker has spent a whole afternoon bothered by a child crying at school. Then, after a dash, comes a blunt admission: "I am he."

The poem never says who the speaker is. A teacher, a parent, a passer-by, or someone remembering their own school days would all fit. That openness matters, because the central idea works on any of them. What annoys us in other people is often what we most recognise in ourselves. The afternoon's irritation was recognition in disguise, and the speaker only understands this when the sentence runs out of room. The poem also allows a more literal reading, in which the speaker is the child, or the child still living inside the adult. The text doesn't choose between them, and the poem is richer for it.

The construction is tight. Counting syllables, the lines run roughly seven, five, two, three. They shrink steadily until "at school" leaves almost nothing, and then "I am he" lands as a small, firm step. The first three lines also form a sentence with no finite verb. "Vexing" and "crying" are only participles, so the thought hangs unfinished, like a held breath. The one true verb in the poem is "am," and it arrives in the last line. The speaker's sense of self completes the sentence the afternoon had left open.

There is no rhyme, but the sound is quietly arranged. The long "i" of "child," "crying" and "I" links the child and the speaker before the poem says they are the same person. "Afternoon" and "school" share an "oo" sound, which places the day and the place in the same echo. Meanwhile "he," an open vowel that can be drawn out, ends the poem where the reader may linger.

The word choices repay attention. "Vexing" is a slightly fussy, old-fashioned word. It names irritation, not sorrow, which tells us the speaker's first response to the crying was annoyance, not tenderness. It is also a transferred epithet. The afternoon is called vexing, but the vexed person is the speaker. "All this" has the tone of someone complaining, and the complaint collapses into confession. The shift from "a child" to "he" is just as telling. The child begins as an anonymous, indefinite figure, one of many. Once the speaker claims him, he becomes definite, and he is no longer a stranger's noise.

"I am he" is itself a curious phrase. In everyday speech most people would say "I am him," but "he" is the formally correct form, and it gives the line a stiff, declarative ring. It sounds like an answer at a roll call, or a person owning up when asked "Who did this?" Judging by the tone, the speaker isn't celebrating the discovery. It is more like being caught. The poem also never says why the child is crying. The speaker's identification replaces any explanation, which suggests that the reason hardly matters. The feeling is what the speaker recognises.

The title adds a quiet irony. "Self-discovery" usually promises a journey, a retreat, or a flash of insight, and here it turns up in the background noise of a school afternoon. The discovery is unwelcome and unplanned, and it comes through a sound the speaker would have preferred to ignore. The poem doesn't tell us whether the speaker feels comforted or ashamed afterwards, and it stops before we find out.

That restraint is what makes it significant. In a few words it shows how thin the boundary between self and other can be, and how often irritation hides empathy. It has the speed of a punchline, but the feeling it leaves is not funny. Readers, especially young ones who know both the crying child and the person who wants it to stop, may recognise themselves in either role, and perhaps in both.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss