War dance — Poem analysis

War gives the world an ill music in praise of the mad.

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Two lines are all Dave Bonta gives us, and the title does half the work. "War dance" puts a body in motion before the poem has said a word: stamping feet, a drumbeat, a crowd moving as one. The lines then supply the soundtrack, "War gives the world an ill music / in praise of the mad", and the dance turns sinister. Whoever is moving to this music, they are not moving freely.

The central idea is that war doesn't only destroy. It also produces a culture of its own, and that culture is sick. The verb is the first surprise. War "gives," like a generous host or a patron, and what it gives is "the world an ill music." The recipient is not a country or an army but the whole world, as though no one could stay out of earshot. Music is what we usually offer as comfort or celebration. Here it arrives as an unwanted gift. "Ill" is a small, flexible word. It can mean sick, as in an ill person, and it can mean malign, as in ill will or an ill omen. Both senses seem to be at work: the music is diseased, and it bodes harm. "An ill music" is also an odd phrase, with an old, ballad-like ring, as if the line were a truth handed down rather than a fresh observation.

The second line holds back its target until the last word. "In praise of" is the language of hymns and odes, so we expect something worth praising, such as the brave, the fallen or the just. We get "the mad." The poem doesn't choose among the meanings. The mad could be the insane, so that war's songs celebrate unreason itself. They could be people driven mad by war, such as soldiers, leaders or crowds whipped into frenzy. Or "mad" could mean furious. Judging by the line alone, the poem wants all of these to hover. The construction "the" plus an adjective is the same one we use for "the brave" or "the faithful." It borrows the dignity of that grammar and fills it with madness.

The sound of the poem supports this. Nearly every word is a single syllable, and the only exception is "music." The one word that ought to be beautiful sits in the middle of blunt, hard-edged neighbours, almost smothered by them. The first line is long and rolling, with about four main beats, and it ends on the unstressed tail of "music," which hangs in the air the way a note trails off. The second line is half the length, two beats, and stops on "mad," a stressed syllable shut by a hard *d*. Read aloud, it feels like a long step followed by a stamp, perhaps the dance in miniature. There is no rhyme, but "music" and "mad" both begin with *m*, so the two ideas are bound together by sound before the sense arrives. Likewise "War" and "world" open the first line with the same *w*, so that war is claiming the world in the very sound of the sentence.

The poem is also notable for what it leaves out. There are no soldiers, no weapons and no blood, and the only sensory image is sound. That restraint matters. Instead of showing war, the poem shows its echo, the way it seeps into what people sing, chant and move to. Nothing names a particular conflict, which makes the claim general. Readers can supply their own examples, whether marching songs, anthems or slogans, though that is our contribution, not something the text states.

The poem's significance lies in this compression. It reads like a proverb: a single sentence, flat and confident, that takes seconds to read and is hard to shake. It also draws the reader in. A dance needs participants, and the title quietly asks who is dancing and why they keep moving when the music is ill. The poem offers no answer, and by ending on the word "mad" it leaves the question hanging.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Painted Trillium

Trillium undulatum Painted lady, late riser, you rush out of the ground, get pollinated on the fly
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Initiation

Let him continue in the ground, he who is now dead, where all things hurry—
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss