The drowned girl — Poem analysis

The apothecary is making with his hands as common as water the bridge to absence where she met her little night.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Five short lines, one sentence, and the girl is already dead before the first word, because the title has done the drowning for us. What remains is a strange scene: an apothecary, a maker of remedies and measured doses, is "making" something with his hands, and what he makes is "the bridge to absence / where she met / her little night." The poem never says who the girl is, where this happens, or whether the apothecary is her healer, her mourner, or something more troubling. Its central idea seems to be that death arrives through ordinary things and is met with ordinary craft. There is no thunder in it, only hands, water, and a crossing.

The apothecary is the most unsettling choice. He belongs to a trade where the same substance can cure or kill, so he carries a faint ambiguity with him. The poem sharpens it with a simile: his hands are "as common as water." Water is the poem's only mention of the element that drowned her, and it appears only as a comparison, never as the event itself. The drowning has been pushed to the edge of the language, which makes it feel both avoided and everywhere. The comparison also cuts two ways. "Common" suggests humble, unmagical hands, hands that could not save her. But water is also what took her, and likening his hands to it quietly hints at an indifference that can give or take life without caring which. The poem doesn't choose between a failed healer and a quiet mourner, and the doubt is where its tension lives.

The syntax does some of the building the poem describes. The sentence breaks after "making with," leaving a dangling preposition that makes us expect a material, something like "making with herbs" or "with glass." Instead we get "his hands as common as water," and only after that gap does the object, "the bridge to absence," finally land. We have to cross the interrupting phrase to reach it, so the sentence becomes a small bridge of its own. The phrase "bridge to absence" is also a paradox. A bridge joins two places, but absence is a lack of place, so the structure leads from presence to nothing, and the traveller never comes back.

The last two lines are the most tender and the most chilling. "Met" makes the drowning sound like an appointment, an encounter with someone, which softens it and gives it an odd intimacy. Then "her little night" shrinks death to the scale of a girl. "Little" is a child's word, affectionate and diminishing, and it makes the darkness something possessive and personal rather than vast and abstract. Judging by the diction, the poem handles grief by understatement, and the smallness of the phrase is what hurts.

The form supports this. There is no rhyme and no regular meter, and apart from the final full stop there is no punctuation, so the sentence is carried by line breaks alone. Counting syllables, the lines run roughly ten, eight, five, three, four, tapering like a pier running out over water. Even the vocabulary shrinks. The poem opens on the long, learned, Latinate "apothecary" and ends in the plain monosyllables "where she met / her little night." We move from a professional title to a girl and her private dark. The short, closed vowels of "hands," "as," and "absence" echo one another and keep the sound low and unshowy, while "night" gives the poem a long vowel to end on.

The poem is significant for what it declines to do. The drowned young woman is a familiar figure in literature, and she is often made decorative or melodramatic. Here there is no name, no scene of rescue, no lament, only a craftsman at work and a crossing. That restraint leaves room for the reader to supply the grief. One could also read the apothecary as a figure for the poet, who makes his bridge from "common" materials, the everyday words that are as available as water, and builds with them a way toward someone who is gone. That reading is an inference from the imagery, but it fits a poem so concerned with hands and making. In five lines it suggests that elegy is a craft, and that every bridge to the dead is built from ordinary things.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss