Laying plans — Poem analysis

Dave BontaContemplative

a rose on ice the children go away to school tomorrow

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Eleven words, and a whole household shifts its weight. Dave Bonta's "Laying plans" gives us a rose, some children and the promise of a school morning, and leaves us to work out how they connect. The most natural reading is that the speaker is a parent, and that the poem catches the moment before the house empties. It holds a mix of anticipation and loss, and it never says which of the two is stronger.

The title does a lot of the work. "Laying plans" is an everyday idiom for making arrangements, but "laying" is also a physical verb, and next to the first line it becomes almost literal: we can picture something being laid down on a cold surface. The plans turn into an object, and that object is the rose. The phrase "on ice" adds another layer, since it also means postponed or put on hold. So the image is both a real flower on real ice and a figure for something delicate and beautiful that has been kept cold and deferred. The poem doesn't say whose plans these are or what they involve. Judging by the way the lines are ordered, they are waiting on the children's departure, and that gap is what makes the poem interesting.

The construction is minimal. The poem looks like a haiku but doesn't follow the 5-7-5 count. Its lines run to roughly four, six and five syllables, so it is slightly shorter than the classic form. There is no rhyme, no capital letter and no punctuation. The first line has no verb at all. "A rose on ice" is a still life, a single frame held in place. Only in the second line does anything move: "the children go away."

That second line is the emotional hinge. Read alone, it sounds large and sad, almost like an elegy, as if the children were leaving for good. "Go away" is also what a harassed parent might say to noisy kids, so a faint note of relief, perhaps tinged with guilt, may be hiding in the phrase. Then the third line, "to school tomorrow," shrinks the departure into routine. The poem makes the reader feel the bigger loss for a moment and then walks it back, and the speaker's feelings seem to move the same way, from the ache of absence to the ordinary fact of a Tuesday. Because there is no full stop, the sentence never quite settles.

The sound of the poem is quiet but deliberate. The long *o* in "rose," "go" and "tomorrow" runs through the three lines like a held note, and the cold hiss of "rose," "ice" and "school" gives the poem a slightly slippery surface, like the ice itself. The last word, "tomorrow," ends on an open vowel and trails off into the future instead of closing. The tenses help too. "Go" is present tense, yet it is tied to tomorrow, so the departure is spoken of as if it were already happening. The plan has been laid, and the speaker is already standing in the quiet it will produce.

The central image is the strangest part. A rose is the traditional emblem of love and desire, and ice is its opposite. Ice can preserve a flower, keeping it looking fresh, but it can also kill it, and the poem doesn't tell us which is happening. The rose could stand for a marriage, a creative ambition or a private self set aside during the busy years of raising children. Whatever it is, it is on ice, suspended rather than lost. The poem leaves open whether tomorrow will thaw it or whether the cold has gone on too long.

That openness is what makes the poem worth reading. It trusts three small images and one word of title to carry a whole situation, and it leaves the reader to supply the rest. The details are domestic, a flower, some children and a school day, yet they hold the feeling of someone arranging their life around other people's needs and waiting for a gap in which to live their own.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss