Peace plan — Poem analysis

We rose early for bullets; one flew off. The mouth of the gun should beg to eat and learn all languages, not smoke and be so illiterate as to welcome absence.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Eight short lines, and a gun is given a mouth, an appetite and a failed education. Compression is the first thing to notice in "Peace plan." The title promises treaties and negotiating tables, but the poem is small enough for a sticky note. It sets out peace in almost domestic terms, as hunger and reading lessons.

The opening is oddly cheerful. "We rose early for bullets" sounds like the start of an ordinary working day, the way someone might rise early for the market. It also quietly echoes the proverb about the early bird, and the next line seems to carry the joke along: "one flew off." Bullets are fired or dropped, but birds fly off. The phrase is slippery, perhaps on purpose. It might mean a shot went astray, or that one bullet escaped the group's control. Either way, the plan has slipped almost before it begins. The poem never says who "we" are, and it names no war, country or side. That leaves the pronoun open to anyone who has ever got up in the dark to do something violent, or merely routine.

Then the poem changes gear. The past tense of the first two lines gives way to "should," and the rest is one long sentence of wishing. The plan itself is strange: "The mouth of the gun / should beg to eat / and learn all languages." Calling a muzzle a mouth is simple personification, but the poem pushes it further. A gun commands, so a gun that begs has already been humbled. The word "eat" may hint at how guns are said to be "fed" with bullets, the very things the speakers rose early to fetch. If so, the wish is for a different kind of nourishment. The mouth would be hungry like a person, not loaded like a weapon. And a mouth that learns "all languages" is no longer a threat. It can listen, translate and answer. The word "all" matters, because the ambition covers every language, not just the enemy's.

The syntax turns on the shortest line in the poem, "not smoke." Up to this point the sentence has described what the mouth should do. After it, the sentence describes what the mouth must stop doing: smoking, and being "so illiterate / as to welcome absence." Smoke is gunsmoke, but a mouth that smokes also sounds like a bad habit, a mouth wasting itself on something that gives nothing back. Notice too that "rose" at the start and "smoke" in the middle both rise, and the long *o* of "rose," "smoke" and "so" faintly connects them. The day begins with rising and ends in vapor.

"Illiterate" is the most surprising word. Nobody usually accuses a gun of failing to read. But the charge turns violence into a kind of ignorance, an inability to read a human being as anything but a target. It also explains why the wish for languages comes first. The poem suggests that killing starts where reading stops.

The last phrase twists a gentle word. To "welcome" is what hosts and open mouths do, but this gun welcomes "absence," meaning the dead, the vanished, or the silence where conversation should have been. Ending on "absence" is a quiet formal move. The poem has no rhyme to click shut, and its lines run from two syllables ("not smoke") to seven ("and be so illiterate"), in plain, mostly one-syllable speech. The final word simply leaves a gap, which suits what it names.

The poem is worth reading for how much it refuses. It offers no sermon, no named conflict and no grand diplomacy. It treats peace as a change in the body of the weapon: the muzzle must stop being a source of smoke and become a place where food goes in and language comes out. The title's bureaucratic phrase "peace plan" makes the whole thing a little ironic, since the only plan on offer is a wish, and it comes after a bullet has already flown off. Yet the wish is precise and memorable. Peace here means learning to read.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss