Schadenfreudian — Poem analysis

Disappointed at home and at the office I count ships

and at night, fires, many in which I took great pleasure.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Six short lines, and the whole poem turns on a pun in its title. "Schadenfreudian" fuses *Schadenfreude*, the pleasure we feel at someone else's misfortune, with *Freudian*, which suggests a hidden motive that slips out against our will. Together the two words tell us what kind of confession to expect. Dave Bonta's speaker is unhappy, and he finds relief not in fixing anything but in watching other people's disasters.

The poem opens with the single word "Disappointed," alone on its line. It is the longest word in the poem and the only one that names a feeling outright, so it sits there like a diagnosis. The next line widens the damage: "at home and at the office." These are the two places where a life is supposed to be made, private and public, and the speaker has been let down in both. The phrasing is flat and almost clerical, with no complaint and no detail about what went wrong. That blankness makes the disappointment feel worn-in and routine.

Then comes the odd, quiet action: "I count ships." Counting is what we do when we have nothing to do, or when we need something steady to hold our attention. It recalls counting sheep to fall asleep. Ships are distant, slow and self-contained, headed somewhere the speaker is not. The line is made of three blunt, stressed beats, and it reads like a shrug. By day, the speaker seems to be looking out at the world without touching it.

The second stanza darkens the picture. "And at night, fires" borrows its verb from the previous stanza. The speaker counts the fires too, as though they were more ships, an inventory of things passing in the distance. The grammar suggests the speaker treats them as equivalent, and the shift from day to night, from ships to flames, moves us from the harmless to the unsettling. The poem never says whose fires these are or whether they are accidents, but the word "fires" is destructive enough that the title's idea of pleasure in misfortune comes into focus.

The final clause is where the poem's craft is most visible: "many in which I took / great pleasure." Notice "in which," a stiff, formal construction, the kind of phrasing found in letters and reports. Using it for such an unattractive admission is darkly funny, like a man confessing to something improper in the language of a memo. The line break after "took" also makes us wait, and the confession lands in the last two words, "great pleasure," which are given the most weight. Both are strong, open sounds, and they are the opposite of the muted "Disappointed" at the start. The word "many" is worth pausing on as well, because it implies that some fires gave no pleasure at all. The speaker is selective and perhaps even has standards, which adds a small, comic note of moral accounting.

There is no rhyme and no regular metre. The poem is free verse, and its music comes from sound and spacing. A soft *sh* sound runs quietly through it: it begins in "Schadenfreudian," returns in "ships," and resolves in "pleasure." That hushed sound makes the poem feel like a murmur or a guilty whisper, and it ties the cheerless first stanza to the confession at the end.

What makes the poem significant is how much honesty fits into so small a space. Most of us know the unlovely comfort of hearing that someone else's day has gone worse than ours, but few of us say so. Here it is said plainly and with no apology, and the speaker never asks to be forgiven. The poem also implicates the reader. Because the voice is so calm, we are never given an easy reason to look down on the speaker, and we may recognise a little of ourselves in him. In under twenty words of body text, it sketches a whole inner weather: dull disappointment, a retreat into watching, and a small, shameful brightness found in someone else's flames.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss