Commission — Poem analysis

Carpenter, make me a door into my life. I am a crow, a plain old woman. I bring none but myself to dinner by the light of the moon. Give me a further gallery in my good ear.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Most of us assume we're already inside our own lives; there's nowhere else to be. Yet the speaker of "Commission" asks a carpenter to build her a way in, as if she had been standing outside all along. That strange request is the poem's central idea. Being present to your own existence is not automatic, and it may need to be made, like a piece of furniture, by someone with skill. What she wants is access and attention, not wealth or youth or fame.

The poem is only seven lines long, with no rhyme and no regular meter, and its shape is simple. Two requests surround a short self-portrait. It opens with "Carpenter, make me" and closes with "Give me a further gallery," both imperatives, both blunt and courteous at once. The first line break is worth a pause. "Make me" hangs there for a moment before "a door into my life" completes it, so for an instant the speaker seems to be asking to be made, not to be given something. The enjambment lets a second, deeper wish show through the practical one.

The middle of the poem is the self-portrait: "I am a crow, a plain old woman." The comma works like an equals sign, joining a metaphor to a flat statement. A crow is black, common and loud, nothing like a nightingale, and the word "plain" makes sure no one mistakes her for something grander. The line is made almost entirely of one-syllable words, which gives it the weight of a plain fact. She doesn't apologise for what she is. She simply declares it.

The next lines turn this plainness into a kind of dignity. "I bring none but myself to dinner" borrows the language of social custom, where a guest arrives with wine or a dish, and then empties it out. Her only offering is her own presence. "None but" has a faintly old-fashioned formality that sits oddly and pleasingly next to the plain speech around it. Then comes "by the light of the moon." Crows are daytime birds, so a moonlit dinner puts her somewhere slightly out of her element, in a dreamlike, late hour. Judging by the imagery, that lateness might hint at old age, though the poem never says so. The soft, repeated *m* sounds of "make me," "my," "myself" and "moon" bind the self and the night together.

The ending contains the poem's most surprising word. A "gallery" can be a balcony, a long passage, or a room where people gather to look and listen. Asking for "a further gallery / in my good ear" turns architecture into hearing. She wants more room inside the way she listens. "Further" suggests an extension, a space reaching beyond the one she already has. The phrase "good ear" quietly implies there is another, lesser ear. She doesn't ask for the weaker one to be mended. She asks for more space in the one that works. That is a modest, realistic wish, and the short, quiet last line, ending on the plain word "ear," leaves it unexaggerated.

So the two requests fit together. A door is for entering, and a gallery is for receiving. One lets her into her life and the other lets her take in what is there. The title adds a final twist. A commission is an order placed with a craftsperson, and here the patron is a plain old woman with nothing to bring but herself. The poem reverses our usual picture of who gets to commission things. The word "Carpenter" may also carry a faint religious echo, but the poem never presses it, and it works perfectly well as a literal request to a builder.

The poem is significant for how much it does with so little. It doesn't describe the door or say what lies beyond it, and it doesn't tell us whether the carpenter agrees. It stays at the moment of asking, which is humble, direct and a little mysterious. After one reading, the line that lingers is probably the odd, specific one about the ear, which makes the longing to listen better feel as practical as carpentry.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss