Short-order cook — Poem analysis

Dave BontaContemplative

The city: a great experiment, there where I never found

a clean plate against tomorrow, paying many little debts

and all things in a hurry of business. As cook, looking over my work,

I ate nothing but bread and cheese and bread and butter.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

A cook who goes hungry is an old irony, but Dave Bonta needs only eight short lines to tell it. The speaker looks back on a stretch of city life as a short-order cook. The city is billed as "a great experiment," yet what he remembers is scarcity, small debts and constant hurry. The central idea is the gap between the city's grand promise and the thin life of the person who feeds it. The man who prepares food for others, who is even "looking over my work," lives on the plainest food there is.

The form is spare. Four unrhymed couplets sit on the page like small order tickets, each holding one thought. Without rhyme, nothing gives the poem a neat chime or comfort. The syntax does the work instead. The first six lines are one long, loose fragment with no main verb. It begins with a colon, as if the city were being defined, and then it piles up clauses: "there where I never found," then "paying many little debts," then "all things in a hurry of business." The grammar feels like tasks stacking up faster than they can be finished. Only in the last couplet does a plain sentence arrive, "I ate nothing but bread and cheese," and its steadiness suggests the speaker has finally stopped to take stock.

The line breaks add pressure of their own. "There where I never found" stops on "found," and the reader has to wait a line to learn what was never found. The answer is "a clean plate against tomorrow." That phrase is the poem's richest image. In a kitchen a clean plate is the basic tool of the trade, and the speaker never has a spare one. It also echoes "a clean slate," a fresh start, which he never gets either. "Against tomorrow" is old-fashioned for "in preparation for the future." The plate is never clean *against tomorrow*, so he lives entirely in the present, with no reserve of dishes, money or time. The debts, meanwhile, are "many" and "little." They are not one dramatic ruin but a slow accumulation of small amounts, which is how most real money trouble arrives.

The poem's pace carries its theme. The title names a job defined by speed, and the phrase "a hurry of business" makes hurry sound like a substance in the air. "All things" is deliberately vague. Everything in the speaker's life seems to be swept into that rush, with nothing separated out. Then comes a small pause: "As cook, looking over my work." For one line he stands back like a craftsman inspecting what he has made. But the next line undercuts any pride, because what he eats is "nothing but bread and cheese / and bread and butter."

That ending is carefully built. The repeated "bread and" works like polysyndeton, the same pattern repeated to make the meals feel monotonous. It is also the poem's shortest line, five syllables against the eight or ten of the lines around it, so the poem seems to run out of food and words together. And "bread and butter" is more than a meal. It is the everyday idiom for earning a living. The literal diet and the job that provides it fold into one phrase, so the man's livelihood and his hunger turn out to be the same thing.

The diction is also worth noticing. Phrases like "against tomorrow," "paying many little debts" and "a hurry of business" sound more formal and older than a diner kitchen. Judging by the language, the poem seems to borrow a register from outside the grill. That mismatch sets lofty, experimental talk about the city against the greasy reality of the work, and it suits a poem about two very different ways of looking at one place.

The poem matters because of its restraint. The speaker never complains, never calls the city unjust, and never says he is hungry. He lists facts in an even voice and leaves the anger to the reader. The result is a quiet question about who pays for a city's "great experiment," and who gets to eat the results.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss