In/mates — Poem analysis

my wife and I dine on a heart nothing but gruel and need

who knows what kind of night began as a cell

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Twenty-three words, no punctuation, not a single capital letter, and a title with a slash through the middle. Dave Bonta's "In/mates" gives a reader very little to hold, which is why each word has to carry so much. The title alone does half the work. Read quickly, it says "inmates": prisoners. Read with the slash, it splits into "in" and "mates", two people inside something together, and "mates" is also an old, warm word for partners. The slash behaves like a bar on a window, but it also looks like a dividing line, a small mark of separation between two halves that belong together. The poem's central idea is already folded into that one character: intimacy can be a form of confinement, and confinement can be a form of intimacy.

The first couplet sets a table. "My wife and I dine on a heart" begins in a plain, domestic voice, but "dine" is a slightly elegant verb, and the thing being eaten is a heart. The image can be read several ways. It might be a shared sacrifice, each partner feeding the other. It might be something more predatory, two people living off one body of feeling. The poem doesn't choose. The next line deflates the elegance. "Nothing but gruel and need" drops from candlelit "dine" to the thin, institutional food of prisons and workhouses. Even the heart, it seems, is a poor meal. Notice too that "need" sits where we expect a second food. Hunger itself is on the menu, so the couple is eating the very thing that makes them eat.

The second couplet shifts from present to past and from statement to question, though there is no question mark. "Who knows what kind of night / began as a cell" sounds like a shrug, the speech of someone who has stopped trying to trace how things got this way. The word "cell" is the hinge of the whole poem, and it holds at least three meanings. It is the prison cell that the title hints at. It is the biological cell, the smallest unit of a body, from which something grows. And the poem suggests a third, quieter possibility: a marriage as a "cell" in the sense of a small, closed unit. If a night can begin as a cell, the confinement may have started as something tiny and then spread into darkness, the way a body grows from a single beginning. Whether that growth is tender, as in a child or a love, or frightening, as in illness, is left open. The poem doesn't say, and that silence is part of what it is saying.

The sound of the poem is quiet but deliberate. Nothing rhymes, yet the long "i" runs through it: "wife," "I," "dine," "kind," "night." That repeated vowel binds the two couplets together without any obvious chime. The lines also shrink as they go, from eight syllables in the first line to six, six, and finally five in "began as a cell." The poem seems to contract around its last word, much as a cell closes around whatever it holds. The "l" of "gruel" also returns in "cell," linking the food to the room. The absence of punctuation lets the lines slide between meanings. "Nothing but gruel and need" can finish the first thought or lean toward the second, and the reader has to decide where a pause belongs.

What makes the poem worth reading is how much pressure it puts on small, ordinary words: "dine," "need," "night," "cell." It doesn't tell us whether the couple is trapped or held, starved or fed. It suggests they are both at once, and that the difference may be impossible to see from inside. For a poem of this size, that is a large idea, and the ambiguity lingers after the last word, much as the title's slash does.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss